Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 23;2014(1):CD000009. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000009.pub4

1. Lengths of follow‐up available for included studies, grouped by intervention type.

Study ID Short‐term outcomes
(≤ 6 weeks after quit date)
Long‐term outcomes
(≥ 6 months after quit date)
Notes
Acupressure
Li 2009 x   Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Tian 1996 x x  
White 2007 x    
Wing 2010 x   Short‐term follow up > 6 weeks (3 months from treatment)
Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Zhang 2013 x   Short‐term follow up > 6 weeks (8 weeks)
Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Acupuncture
Bier 2002 (x) (x) Data not consistent so not included in any meta‐analysis
Circo 1985 x    
Clavel 1985 x x  
Clavel 1992 x x  
Cottraux 1983 x x  
Gilbey 1977 x   Also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Gillams 1984 x x Also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Han 2006 (x)   Compares acupuncture with acupuncture, not included in any meta‐analyses
He 1997 x x Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Huang 2012 x   Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Labadie 1983 x x Short‐term follow up >6 weeks (8 weeks)
Lacroix 1977 x    
Lagrue 1980 x    
Lamontagne 1980 x x  
Leung 1991 x x  
Martin 1981a; Martin 1981b x x Also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Parker 1977a; Parker 1977b x   Parker 1977a also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Steiner 1982 x    
Vandevenne 1985 x x  
Vibes 1977 x   Also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Waite 1998 x x Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
White 1998 x x  
Wu 2007 x x Also in continuous stimulation (indwelling needle) subgroup
Electrostimulation
Antoniou 2005 x    
Aycicegi‐Dinn 2011 x    
Fritz 2013 x    
Georgiou 1999 x    
Pickworth 1997 x    
Scheuer 2005 x x  
Yeh 2009 x   Also in continuous stimulation (acupressure) subgroup
Laser therapy
Cai 2000 x    
Docherty 2003   x  
Kerr 2008 x x