Table 2.
Performance characteristics of Orient Gene Biotech LFA and Wantai ELISA in patients with suspected COVID-19 compared with nucleic acid amplification tests as reference standard
All patients | Time from symptom onset to sample collection <7 days a | Time from symptom onset to sample collection ≥7 days a | p | Non-ICU | ICU | p | CRP <100 mg/L | CRP ≥100 mg/L | p | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Orient Gene Biotech LFA | ||||||||||
Sensitivity | 43/99 (43; 95% CI 34–53) | 11/39 (28; 95% CI 14–42) | 31/52 (60; 95% CI 46–73) | <0.01 | 35/83 (42; 95% CI 32–53) | 8/16 (50; 95% CI 26–75) | 0.56 | 22/66 (33; 95% CI 22–45) | 21/33 (64; 95% CI 47–80) | <0.01 |
Specificity | 126/129 (98; 95% CI 95–100) | 39/40 (98; 95% CI 93–100) | 48/50 (96; 95% CI 91–100) | 0.96 | 122/124 (98; 95% CI 96–100) | 4/5 (80; 95% CI 45–100) | <0.01 | 109/111 (98; 95% CI 96–100) | 17/18 (94; 95% CI 84–100) | 0.33 |
Wantai ELISAb | ||||||||||
Sensitivity | 59/95 (62; 95% CI 52–72) | 19/39 (49; 95% CI 33–64) | 38/48 (79; 95% CI 68–91) | <0.01 | 49/80 (61; 95% CI 51–72) | 10/15 (67; 95% CI 43–91) | 0.69 | 36/65 (55; 95% CI 43–68) | 23/30 (77; 95% CI 62–92 | 0.047 |
Specificity | 125/128 (98; 95% CI 95–100) | 39/40 (98; 95% CI 93–100) | 48/50 (96; 95% CI 91–100) | 1.00 | 121/123 (98; 95% CI 96–100) | 4/5 (80; 95% CI 45–100) | 0.11 | 108/110 (98; 95% CI 96–100) | 17/18 (94; 95% CI 84–100) | 0.37 |
Abbreviations: CRP, C-reactive protein; ICU, intensive care unit; LFA, lateral flow immunochromatographic assays.
Data are presented in absolute numbers (percentages). Of note, sensitivity was 17/24 (71%) in patients with ≥7 days from symptom onset to sample collection and CRP was ≥100 mg/L.
In some patients time from symptom onset was undetermined or unavailable. In the subgroup of patients with time from symptom onset to sample collection ≥14 days, sensitivity and specificity of the LFA were 9/14 (64%; 95% CI 39%–89%) and 30/32 (94%; 95% CI 85%–100%), respectively, whereas sensitivity and specificity of the ELISA were 6/12 (50%; 95% CI 22%–78%) and 30/32 (94%; 95% CI 85%–100%), respectively.
5/228 (2%) samples were unavailable for ELISA.