Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Jun 5.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Chest Med. 2016 Oct 14;37(4):753–763. doi: 10.1016/j.ccm.2016.07.014

Table 1.

Prolonged mechanical ventilation settings for care

Setting Pros Cons
ICU Optimal medical and staffing resources to respond to changes in respiratory status
  • High costs of care

  • Limited Medicare reimbursement

  • Competing bed space with the acutely ill

  • Limited psychosocial and family support

LTAC
  • Designed to support acute care patients requiring specialized care and rehabilitation services

  • Lower costs compared with ICUs

  • Higher discharge reimbursements compared with ICUs

  • Increased patient/staff ratios may jeopardize care compared with ICUs

  • Long-term goals of care are to wean off ventilators or to transition to home, not to support lifetime PMV

Nursing home
  • Alternative to at-home care when family support and/or resources are inadequate

  • Can support those requiring lifetime PMV, and those who may be weaned in time

  • Varying accessibility of facilities

  • Must be medically stable

  • Lower discharge reimbursements compared with LTAC facilities

Home
  • Increased quality of life through family caregiving, psychosocial support, and increased patient autonomy

  • Most cost-effective setting

  • Reduced infection rates

  • Must be medically stable

  • Requires a stable and safe home environment

  • Requires considerable family and professional caregiver support

  • Continued emergency response education required for all caregivers