Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Adv Healthc Mater. 2020 Mar 17;9(8):e1901682. doi: 10.1002/adhm.201901682

Table 1.

List of important structural and mechanical features investigated in fibrosis platforms, commonly used biomaterials to model these features, and representative experimental outcomes.

Material Features Biomaterials Investigated Representative Outcomes
Stiffness 2D: Alginate, HA, PDMS, PEG, PAA Stiff, relative to normal tissue stiffness, biomaterials:
  • Promote myofibroblast activation [74] and epithelial cell dysfunction [47]

  • Promote decreased mesenchymal cell migration rate [142]

Soft biomaterials:
  • Promote fibroblast quiescence and epithelial cell differentiation

  • Promote cell-cell interactions over cell-material interactions

Dimensionality 2D: Alginate, HA, PDMS, PEG, PAA
2.5D: Electrospun Dextran/HA/PEG Fibrin, Collagen
3D: Alginate, Dextran, HA, PEG, Polypeptides, Fibrin, Collagen
2.5D biomaterials (e.g., electrospun and natural fibrillar proteins):
  • Promote cell spreading, unless adhesive area is limited [103]

  • Direct cell morphology with underlying topography (e.g., aligned or random)

3D biomaterials:h
  • Support cell spreading and cell-cell interactions when the hydrogel is degradable or can be remodeled [57,66]

Viscoelasticity 2D: Alginate, HA, PAA, PDMS, PEG
3D: Alginate, HA, PEG
Viscoelastic biomaterials:
  • Reduce cell spreading in stiff environments, while promoting spreading in soft environments[100]

  • Promote cell spreading with fast stress relaxation and prevents cell spreading with slow stress relaxation[64,65]

Deformability 2D: Alginate, PEG
2.5D: Electrospun Dextran/HA/PEG, Fibrin, Collagen
3D: Alginate, HA, PEG, Fibrin, Collagen
Extensible (soft) fibrous materials:
  • Support cell spreading[103], myofibroblast activation[99] and cell-cell mechanical coupling through the matrix[109]

  • May locally stiffen through physical remodeling of the matrix[143]

Non-extensible (stiff) fibrous materials:
  • Limit physical remodeling of the matrix, as well as reduce cell spreading and myofibroblast activation

Plasticity 2.5D: Electrospun Dextran Fibrin, Collagen
3D: Alginate, Fibrin, Collagen
Plastically deformable hydrogels:
  • Support cell spreading and cell migration through 3D environments[114]

  • Support residual alignment of the matrix after cell remodeling[3]

Porosity Nanoscale:
Alginate, Dextran, HA, PEG
Microscale:
Alginate, HA
Electrospun Dextran/HA/PEG
Fibrin, Collagen
Nanoscale porosity:
  • Limits cell migration and spreading unless polymer or crosslinks can be remodeled/degraded

Microscale porosity:
  • Permits cell migration and spreading if pores are large enough for cell components (e.g., nucleus, cytoskeleton) to fit through

2D: two-dimensions, 3D: three-dimensions, HA: hyaluronic acid, PEG: polyethylene glycol, PDMS: polydimethylsiloxane, PAA: polyacrylamide