Skip to main content
. 2020 May 11;12(5):442. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics12050442

Table 3.

Advantages and disadvantages of different drug-loading methods.

Drug-Loading Method Advantage Disadvantage Reference
Incubation
  • Simple

  • No additional equipment required

  • Not affect the EVs (size and morphology)

  • Low loading capacity

[73,79,80,81,88]
Sonication
  • High loading capacity,

  • Able to load anticancer drugs, siRNAs and proteins

  • Not suitable for hydrophobic drugs

[79,80,82]
Electroporation
  • Able to load large molecules (nucleic acids such as antisense oligo nuclides, siRNA, miRNA and genomic RNA) and anticancer drugs

  • Moderate loading capacity

  • Deformation the EVs

  • siRNA aggregation

  • Low loading capacity compared to sonication or saponin

[64,79,82,83,88,97]
Freeze-Thaw
  • Simple

  • Moderate of loading capacity

  • Membrane fusion is possible: Generation of Hybrid EVMs from EVs and liposomes

  • Low loading efficiency compared to extrusion and sonication

  • Aggregation of EVs

[80,81]
Saponification
  • Simple

  • Higher drug-loading capacity

  • Requires a recovery phase before use

  • Saponin is a toxic agent

  • Requires additional washing (affect the integrity of EVs)

  • Using a saponin control-EVs is must

[80,81,87,98]
Transfection reagents
  • Simple

  • Able to load nucleic acids

  • Expensive

  • siRNA also isolated with EVs (high centrifugal forces)

  • Transfection reagent may associate with siRNA and delivered into recipient cells

  • Mechanism of action for reagents not well-known

[91,92,99]
Extrusion
  • Highest loading of any kinds of drugs

  • Generation of Hybrid EVMs from EVs and liposomes

  • Deformation of membrane

[80,81,85,86,87,97]
Drug Treatment of Parental Cells
  • Simple

  • No Additional Equipment Required

  • Low loading capacity

  • Loading may harm the cells

  • Cells lead to release unwanted materials into EVs.

  • Activation of apoptotic bodies may contaminate the isolated EVs

[93]
Gene Engineering of Parental Cells
  • High packaging efficiency

  • Guaranteed loading

  • How it works remain elusive

  • Mostly used to load nucleic acids

[94,95]

EV, extracellular vesicle; EVMs, extracellular vesicle mimetics; siRNA, small interfering RNA; miRNA, microRNA.