Skip to main content
. 2020 May 13;20(10):2770. doi: 10.3390/s20102770

Table 1.

Sleep studies with closed-loop feedback systems.

Literature Stimulus Type Control Parameters Behavioral Effects
Mouze-Amady et al. [49] Acoustic White noise stimulation at REM detection Prolonged REM duration
Ngo et al. [36,37] Acoustic Pink noise at up-state SW Declarative memory improvement
Besedovsky et al. [52] Acoustic Pink noise at up-state SW Regulating immune-supportive function
Santostasi et al. [38]
Ong et al. [39,75]
Papalambros et al. [40]
Leminen et al. [41]
Acoustic Phase-locked pink noise on SO Declarative memory improvement
Bergmann et al. [45] TMS TMS at up-state SW -
Lustenberger et al. [46] tACS spindle-like tACS at spindle activity Procedural memory improvement
Henin et al. [72] Acoustic Pink noise at up-state SW -
Choi et al. [64] Acoustic Pink noise at spindle activity Procedural memory improvement
Robinson et al. [53] tACS SW-like tACS in phase with SW oscillations Improved subjective sleep quality
Ketz et al. [54] tACS SW-like tACS in phase with SW oscillations Improved long-term memory generalization
Pilly et al. [74] tDCS & tACS TMR at up-state SW Targeted memory improvement
Choi et al. [42] Vibration Vibration stimuli with a relative heart rate change Stabilized the autonomic nervous system
Antony et al. [65] Acoustic TMR after spindle activity Improved declarative memory
Ngo et al. [66] Acoustic Spindle-frequency AM-WN stimulation at up-state SW -
Fattinger et al. [67] Acoustic Spindle-frequency AM-WN stimulation at up-state SW -