Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 4;11:501. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.00501

Table 2.

Description of the studies that have been analyzed the physiological AL parameters and the effects of physical activity and yoga asanas on anxiety and depression outcome.

Study Type of study Study participants Physical activity Concomitant
treatment
AL parameters
measured
Depression/Anxiety outcome Main conclusion
Physical Activity (Aerobic Exercises, strengthening activities, leisure - physical activity surveys)
Bennie et al. (101)
USA
Cross-sectional data analyses from
health surveillance surveys
(2011–2017).
n=1,477,981 adults (≥18 years).
n=286,325
(18.0%) had depression.
Self reported physical activity survey.
Physical activity was classified as aerobic and non-aerobic,
and moderate intensity or vigorous intensity.
Not reported Body Mass Index
Diabetes
Hypertension
Arthritis
Subjects were analyzed
in stratified sub-
groups to reduce cofounders.
AL outcomes were not reported.
All physical activity combinations were associated with lower prevalence of depression Lowest prevalence of depression was shown for those
combining aerobic physical activity, or muscle strengthening
activities, ≥2 days/week.
Fernandez-Montero et al. (102)
Spain
Prospective study of physical activity and risk of depression n=15,488
adults,
follow-up of
10.5 years.
Leisure physical activity questionnaire
(hours/week).
Not reported Hypertension, Diabetes mellitus
Weight
(Analyzed as cofounders).
A total of 870 incident cases of
depression
Participants with higher total leisure physical activity exhibited a lower risk of depression.
Gomes et al. (23)
Brazil
Prospective study of adiposity, inflammatory markers, depression and anxiety n=2,977 Cohort followed-up from birth until 18 and 22 years old International Physical Activity Questionnaire
(IPAQ)
No Body mass index
Fat mass index
Waist circumference
C-reactive protein
IL-6
A bidirectional association between obesity and depression was found.
The effect of obesity on depression was more consistent than on anxiety.
Depression, but not generalized anxiety disorder, was associated with adiposity.
Decreased levels of physical activity may mediate the association between obesity and depression.
Harvey et al. (100)
Norway
Prospective study about exercise and the prevention of depression. n=33,908
Cohort of healthy adults
were followed for 11 years.
Validated questioners of exercise. No Body Mass Index,
resting pulse.
Less exercise at baseline was associated with higher resting pulse.
22,564 individuals followed up, 1,578 (7.0%) developed
depression and 1,972 (8.7%) anxiety.
Regular leisure-time exercise of any intensity provided protection against future depression but not anxiety.
Herbsleb et al. (104)
Germany
Cardio-respiratory fitness and autonomic function in patients with major depressive disorder n= 34 patients with depression
and normal controls
International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) Conventional treatments
(Antidepressants)
Hear rate, blood pressure, body fat,
body mass index.
Cardiopulmonary exercise test.
A negative correlation between depression and the IPAQ was found in patients with depression. A lower fitness level in cardiopulmonary exercise test was observed in patients with depression.
Kerling et al.
(105)
Germany
Adjunctive exercise in depression: a randomized pilot trial n=42
consecutive inpatients with major depressive disorder
Training program; three sessions per week, 45 minutes, moderate intensity compared to a group with usual treatment Psychotherapy (100%) and antidepressants (75-77%) Espiroergometry
Lipids
VO2 uptake
Lactate levels
Exercise group showed lower heart rate, diastolic blood pressure, waist circumference, and higher HDL cholesterol and depression improvement. Exercise improves the outcome of inpatient treatment of moderate to severe depression.
Philippot et al. (109)
Belgium
A pilot
randomised trial of physical exercise on
depression and anxiety symptoms
n=27
Healthy pre-adolescents
age=9-11 years.
5-week period of intensive or low-to moderate
exercises, four times a week.
No Body mass index,
body fat.
No significant differences were found after treatment.
Psychological self-reports of depression and anxiety were
reduced.
The program focused
on associating movement with pleasure, encouraged positive and non-competitive
interactions between participants
Schuchet al.
(103)
Brazil
Effects of aerobic physical exercise as an add-on strategy; A randomized controlled trial n=26
Severe depressed inpatients.
Aerobic physical exercise 16.5 kcal/kg/week, three times a week Conventional treatments (pharmacotherapy and/or electroconvulsive therapy) Weight. No AL outcomes were measured. A significant reduction in depression symptoms scores was observed in the exercise group. Physical exercise could be a feasible and effective add-on strategy for treatment of severe depressed inpatients.
Valentine et al. (106)
USA
Sex differences between obesity, C-reactive protein, physical activity, depression and fatigue n=127
community-dwelling
older adults
Physical Activity Scale for the Elderly (PASE) No Body Mass
% Fat
Index
C-Reactive Protein
Inflammation was positively associated with fatigue and depression, and inversely associated with physical activity and % fat in women. Strategies to prevent fatigue and depression may differ in older women and men, especially with regard to inflammation, physical activity and adiposity.
Yoga (Hatha Yoga/asanas)
Gothe et al.
(107)
USA
A randomized control study
Effects of Yoga on executive function and stress
n = 118
healthy
adults
An 8-week yoga intervention or a stretching control group. No Salivary
cortisol
Executive functions, self-reported stress and anxiety Yoga participants showed improvement in executive functions and showed an attenuated cortisol response.
West et al. (108)
USA

Effects of hatha yoga and African dance on perceived stress and affect. 69 healthy undergraduate students. Different interventions in 3 groups of patients:
African dance, hatha yoga, and biology lecture (control group).
No Salivary
cortisol levels were
decreased in yoga group.
Perceived Stress, Affect (positive and negative affect schedule). African dance and hatha yoga significantly decreased perceived stress and negative affect, compared to the biology class.