Table 2.
Study | Type of study | Study participants | Physical activity | Concomitant treatment |
AL parameters measured |
Depression/Anxiety outcome | Main conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Physical Activity (Aerobic Exercises, strengthening activities, leisure - physical activity surveys) | |||||||
Bennie et al. (101) USA |
Cross-sectional data analyses from health surveillance surveys (2011–2017). |
n=1,477,981 adults (≥18 years). n=286,325 (18.0%) had depression. |
Self reported physical activity survey. Physical activity was classified as aerobic and non-aerobic, and moderate intensity or vigorous intensity. |
Not reported | Body Mass Index Diabetes Hypertension Arthritis Subjects were analyzed in stratified sub- groups to reduce cofounders. AL outcomes were not reported. |
All physical activity combinations were associated with lower prevalence of depression | Lowest prevalence of depression was shown for those combining aerobic physical activity, or muscle strengthening activities, ≥2 days/week. |
Fernandez-Montero et al. (102) Spain |
Prospective study of physical activity and risk of depression | n=15,488 adults, follow-up of 10.5 years. |
Leisure physical activity questionnaire (hours/week). |
Not reported | Hypertension, Diabetes mellitus Weight (Analyzed as cofounders). |
A total of 870 incident cases of depression |
Participants with higher total leisure physical activity exhibited a lower risk of depression. |
Gomes et al. (23) Brazil |
Prospective study of adiposity, inflammatory markers, depression and anxiety | n=2,977 Cohort followed-up from birth until 18 and 22 years old | International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) |
No | Body mass index Fat mass index Waist circumference C-reactive protein IL-6 |
A bidirectional association between obesity and depression was found. The effect of obesity on depression was more consistent than on anxiety. |
Depression, but not generalized anxiety disorder, was associated with adiposity. Decreased levels of physical activity may mediate the association between obesity and depression. |
Harvey et al. (100) Norway |
Prospective study about exercise and the prevention of depression. | n=33,908 Cohort of healthy adults were followed for 11 years. |
Validated questioners of exercise. | No | Body Mass Index, resting pulse. Less exercise at baseline was associated with higher resting pulse. |
22,564 individuals followed up, 1,578 (7.0%) developed depression and 1,972 (8.7%) anxiety. |
Regular leisure-time exercise of any intensity provided protection against future depression but not anxiety. |
Herbsleb et al. (104) Germany |
Cardio-respiratory fitness and autonomic function in patients with major depressive disorder | n= 34 patients with depression and normal controls |
International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) | Conventional treatments (Antidepressants) |
Hear rate, blood pressure, body fat, body mass index. Cardiopulmonary exercise test. |
A negative correlation between depression and the IPAQ was found in patients with depression. | A lower fitness level in cardiopulmonary exercise test was observed in patients with depression. |
Kerling et al. (105) Germany |
Adjunctive exercise in depression: a randomized pilot trial | n=42 consecutive inpatients with major depressive disorder |
Training program; three sessions per week, 45 minutes, moderate intensity compared to a group with usual treatment | Psychotherapy (100%) and antidepressants (75-77%) | Espiroergometry Lipids VO2 uptake Lactate levels |
Exercise group showed lower heart rate, diastolic blood pressure, waist circumference, and higher HDL cholesterol and depression improvement. | Exercise improves the outcome of inpatient treatment of moderate to severe depression. |
Philippot et al. (109) Belgium |
A pilot randomised trial of physical exercise on depression and anxiety symptoms |
n=27 Healthy pre-adolescents age=9-11 years. |
5-week period of intensive or low-to moderate exercises, four times a week. |
No | Body mass index, body fat. No significant differences were found after treatment. |
Psychological self-reports of depression and anxiety were reduced. |
The program focused on associating movement with pleasure, encouraged positive and non-competitive interactions between participants |
Schuchet al. (103) Brazil |
Effects of aerobic physical exercise as an add-on strategy; A randomized controlled trial | n=26 Severe depressed inpatients. |
Aerobic physical exercise 16.5 kcal/kg/week, three times a week | Conventional treatments (pharmacotherapy and/or electroconvulsive therapy) | Weight. No AL outcomes were measured. | A significant reduction in depression symptoms scores was observed in the exercise group. | Physical exercise could be a feasible and effective add-on strategy for treatment of severe depressed inpatients. |
Valentine et al. (106) USA |
Sex differences between obesity, C-reactive protein, physical activity, depression and fatigue | n=127 community-dwelling older adults |
Physical Activity Scale for the Elderly (PASE) | No | Body Mass % Fat Index C-Reactive Protein |
Inflammation was positively associated with fatigue and depression, and inversely associated with physical activity and % fat in women. | Strategies to prevent fatigue and depression may differ in older women and men, especially with regard to inflammation, physical activity and adiposity. |
Yoga (Hatha Yoga/asanas) | |||||||
Gothe et al. (107) USA |
A randomized control study Effects of Yoga on executive function and stress |
n = 118 healthy adults |
An 8-week yoga intervention or a stretching control group. | No | Salivary cortisol |
Executive functions, self-reported stress and anxiety | Yoga participants showed improvement in executive functions and showed an attenuated cortisol response. |
West et al. (108) USA |
Effects of hatha yoga and African dance on perceived stress and affect. | 69 healthy undergraduate students. | Different interventions in 3 groups of patients: African dance, hatha yoga, and biology lecture (control group). |
No | Salivary cortisol levels were decreased in yoga group. |
Perceived Stress, Affect (positive and negative affect schedule). | African dance and hatha yoga significantly decreased perceived stress and negative affect, compared to the biology class. |