Skip to main content
. 2020 May 26;5(22):13303–13311. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.0c01348

Table 2. Aboveground Biomass, N Accumulation, NAE, NPFP, and NUE for Different Treatments in 2016–2018a.

year treatment biomass (kg ha–1) N accumulation (kg ha–1) NAE (kg N kg–1) NPFP (kg N kg–1) NUE (%) NUE change relative to CP0 (%)
2016 CK 11,485d 83.1d        
CFF 14,659c 139.2c 10.4d 42.5d 31.2c  
CP0 16,337b 147.6b 13.3c 45.4c 35.9b  
CP1 17,920a 157.3a 18.8a 50.9a 41.3a 15.1
CP2 17,669a 147.8b 17.0ab 49.1ab 36.0b 0.3
CP3 16,577b 148.4b 15.8b 47.9b 36.3b 1.2
2017 CK 12,249d 84.6d        
CFF 13,511c 140.3c 2.9c 37.8c 30.9c  
CP0 16,082b 153.5b 10.9b 45.8b 38.3b  
CP1 17,410a 164.8a 15.1a 50.0a 44.6a 16.4
CP2 16,651ab 152.3b 11.3b 46.2b 37.6b –1.8
CP3 16,392b 147.6bc 10.4b 45.3b 35.0bc –8.6
2018 CK 10,902d 80.9d        
CFF 14,232c 127.4c 9.8c 39.6c 25.8c  
CP0 16,173ab 150.3b 15.7b 45.5b 38.6b  
CP1 17,153a 164.4a 19.6a 49.4a 46.4a 20.2
CP2 16,671b 148.8b 16.8b 46.6b 37.7b –2.2
CP3 15,993b 150.3b 15.5b 45.3b 38.5b –0.1
a

Note: Means followed by same the lowercase letter within each column in the same year were not significantly different (p > 0.05) based on analysis by one-way ANOVAs followed by Duncan multiple range tests.