Table 2. Aboveground Biomass, N Accumulation, NAE, NPFP, and NUE for Different Treatments in 2016–2018a.
year | treatment | biomass (kg ha–1) | N accumulation (kg ha–1) | NAE (kg N kg–1) | NPFP (kg N kg–1) | NUE (%) | NUE change relative to CP0 (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2016 | CK | 11,485d | 83.1d | ||||
CFF | 14,659c | 139.2c | 10.4d | 42.5d | 31.2c | ||
CP0 | 16,337b | 147.6b | 13.3c | 45.4c | 35.9b | ||
CP1 | 17,920a | 157.3a | 18.8a | 50.9a | 41.3a | 15.1 | |
CP2 | 17,669a | 147.8b | 17.0ab | 49.1ab | 36.0b | 0.3 | |
CP3 | 16,577b | 148.4b | 15.8b | 47.9b | 36.3b | 1.2 | |
2017 | CK | 12,249d | 84.6d | ||||
CFF | 13,511c | 140.3c | 2.9c | 37.8c | 30.9c | ||
CP0 | 16,082b | 153.5b | 10.9b | 45.8b | 38.3b | ||
CP1 | 17,410a | 164.8a | 15.1a | 50.0a | 44.6a | 16.4 | |
CP2 | 16,651ab | 152.3b | 11.3b | 46.2b | 37.6b | –1.8 | |
CP3 | 16,392b | 147.6bc | 10.4b | 45.3b | 35.0bc | –8.6 | |
2018 | CK | 10,902d | 80.9d | ||||
CFF | 14,232c | 127.4c | 9.8c | 39.6c | 25.8c | ||
CP0 | 16,173ab | 150.3b | 15.7b | 45.5b | 38.6b | ||
CP1 | 17,153a | 164.4a | 19.6a | 49.4a | 46.4a | 20.2 | |
CP2 | 16,671b | 148.8b | 16.8b | 46.6b | 37.7b | –2.2 | |
CP3 | 15,993b | 150.3b | 15.5b | 45.3b | 38.5b | –0.1 |
Note: Means followed by same the lowercase letter within each column in the same year were not significantly different (p > 0.05) based on analysis by one-way ANOVAs followed by Duncan multiple range tests.