Table 7.
Design of trials with a focus on general health, preventive health, health beliefs, and other topics.
Reference | Topic | Setting/country/population | Study design | Experimental arm vs control arm(s), n | Intervention description and control | Duration |
Moniz et al (2015) [49] | Preventive health behaviors (smoking cessation, condom use, nutrition optimization, seat belt use, breastfeeding) | Prenatal clinic/Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States/<28 weeks’ gestation | Observational | Intervention (171), no control arm | General preventive health text messages regarding tobacco cessation, sexually transmitted disease prevention, daily vitamin use, seat belt use, dietary discretion and breastfeeding | 12 weeks |
Dalrymple et al (2013) [50] | General prenatal health topics | Prenatal clinic/Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States/no special population | Observational | Intervention (31), no control arm | Twice weekly text messages delivered alongside text4baby messages on days text4baby messages were not sent | Unclear |
Bush (2017) [51] | Numerous including weight, milestones, Wyoming-specific resources | Online/Wyoming state, United States/Medicaid users | Observation | Intervention (85) vs non–app-Medicaid members (5158) | Wyhealth Due Date Plus: mobile phone app that includes information on 70 health risk factors, provides pregnancy timeline, weight tracker, and appointment reminders | 6 months |
Krishnamurti (2017) [52] | Numerous, including nutrition, routine prenatal care, violence, smoking, preterm labor | Prenatal clinic/Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States/Medicaid-qualifying women | Observation | Intervention (16), no control arm | My Healthy Pregnancy App: Interactive application that gathered data regarding risk factors and delivered patient-specific risk feedback and recommendations. Could also arrange for Uber rides to clinic | 3 months or until delivery |
Ledford (2016) [53] | General obstetric care, health literacy | Prenatal clinic/Bethesda, MD, United States/10-12 weeks’ gestation | RCTa | Intervention (87) vs control (86) | Mobile app for journaling with space for recording weight, blood pressure, and experience between prenatal appointments vs spiral notebook alone | Until 32 weeks’ gestation |
Evans et al (2014) [54] | General prenatal health topics | Army Medical Center/Tacoma, WA, United States/<14 weeks’ gestation | RCT | Intervention (498) vs control (498) | Text messages: 3 automated, tailored text messages per week vs usual care | 4 weeks |
Evans et al (2012) [55] | General prenatal health topics | Prenatal clinic/Fairfax county, VA, United States/largely low-income | RCT | Intervention (48) vs control (38) | Automated, tailored text messages vs usual care | 28 weeks’ gestation |
Takeuchi (2016) [56] | Perineal massage | Prenatal clinic/Tokyo, Japan/30-33 weeks’ gestation | RCT | Intervention (81) vs control (80) | Mobile phone website underlining effects of perineal massage, massage technique, support through peer group, communication with professional, and reminders/encouragement vs leaflet alone | Until delivery |
aRCT: randomized controlled trial.