Table A2.
Nacul et al., [26] | Lindal et al., [13] | Rimes et al., [27] | |
---|---|---|---|
Title and abstract | |||
1a. Indicate the study design | Yes | Yes | Yes |
1b. Informative and balanced abstract | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Introduction | |||
2. Background/rationale | Yes | Yes | Yes |
3. Objectives | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Methods | |||
4. Study design | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
5. Setting | Yes | Yes | No/Unclear |
6a. Participants | Yes | Yes | Yes |
7. Variables | Yes | Yes | Yes |
8. Data sources/measurement | Yes | Yes | Yes |
9. Bias | No/Unclear | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
10. Study size | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
12a. Statistics: description of all methods | Yes | Yes | Yes |
12b. Statistics: subgroups and interactions | Yes | Yes | Yes |
12c. Statistics: missing data | Yes | Yes | Yes |
12d. Statistics: loss to follow-up | Yes | Not applicable | Yes |
12e. Statistics: sensitivity analyses | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
Results | |||
13a. Participants: individual at each stage | Yes | Yes | Yes |
13b. Participants: reasons for non-participation | Yes | No/Unclear | Yes |
13c. Participants: flow diagram | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
14a. Descriptive data: characteristics of participants | Yes | Yes | Yes |
14b. Descriptive data: missing data | Yes | Yes | Yes |
14c. Descriptive data: follow-up | Yes | Not applicable | Yes |
15. Outcome data | Yes | Yes | Yes |
16a. Main results | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Discussion | |||
18. Key results | Yes | Yes | Yes |
19. Limitations | Yes | Yes | Yes |
20. Interpretation | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
21. Generalisability | Yes | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
Other information | |||
22. Funding | No/Unclear | No/Unclear | No/Unclear |
Note. The following items are not displayed in the figure as they were not applicable to the included studies: 6b, 11, 16b, 16c, 17.