Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 12;15(6):e0234722. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0234722

Table 2. A brief summary of the included studies.

Reference Sample (Feature) size Outcomes Predictors/variables/features Missing values handled Hyperparameter selection Validation Calibration Best Algorithm Compared algorithms
Al Taleb et al. 2017 358 (15) Length of Stay At admission Single imputation Not reported 10-fold CV No Bayesian Network DT (C4.5)
Asadi et al. 2014 107 (8) 90-day binary and 7 scale mRS At admission Not reported No Training, test, validation for ANN, Nested CV for SVM No SVM ANN, Linear Regression
Liang et al. 2019 435 (4) 90-day binary mRS Admission, laboratory data Not reported Not reported Training and test split No ANN LR
Heo et al. 2019 2604 (38) 90-day binary mRS Admission Complete case analysis No Training and test split No DNN RF, LR
Konig et al. 2007 3184 (43) 100-day Bathel Index first 72h after admission Complete case analysis Yes, Grid search Temporal and external validation Yes for LR - RF, SVM, LR
Celik et al. 2014 570 (22) 10-day mortality At admission - Yes, grid search 5-fold CV No LR ANN
Ho et al. 2014 190 (26) Discharge mortality Admission and interventions Complete case analysis Not reported 10-fold CV No SVM Naïve Bayes, DT, RF, PCA+SVM, LR
Cox et al. 2016 2580 (72) Post stroke spasticity Not clear Not reported Not reported Training, test and validation split No RF DT (CART), Adaboost
Kruppa et al. 2014 3184 (43) 100-day Bathel Index First 72h after admission data Complete case analysis Yes, For KNN, bNN and RF Temporal and external validation Yes, Brier score SVM and LR K-NN, b-NN, RF
Easton et al. 2014 933 (-) Short/very short mortality Not clear Not reported Yes, DT is pruned Training and test split No - Naïve Bayes, DT, LR
Mogensen and Gerds 2013 516 (12) 3-month/1-year/3-year/5-year mortality Admissiondata Complete case analysis No, manually set up Bootstrap CV Yes, Brier score - Pseudo RF, Cox Regression, and Random survival forest
Van Os et al. 2018 1383 (83) Good reperfusion socre, 3-month binary mRS Admission, laboratory and treatment data Multiple imputation by chained equations Yes, nested CV with random grid search Nested CV No - RF, SVM, ANN, super learner, LR
Peng et al. 2010 423 (10) 30-day mortality Admission, laboratory, radiographic data No missing values Yes, empirically 4-fold CV No RF ANN, SVM, LR
Tokmakci et al. 2008 70 (6) Quality of life Admissiondata Not reported Not reported Training and test split No ANFIS
Monteiro et al. 2018 425 (152) 3-month binary mRS Admission/2 hours/24 hours/7 days data single imputation Yes, Grid search 10-fold CV No RF and Xgboost DT, SVM, RF, LR (LASSO)
Tjortjis et al. 2007 671 (37) 2-month mortality Admission data Cases discarded with missing outcomes Yes, pruned Training and test split No DT (T3) DT (C4.5)
Lin et al. 2018 382 (5) Neurologic deterioration Admission and laboratory data Not reported Yes, CV Training and test split No - SVM
Tanioka et al. 2019 95 (20) Delayed cerebral ischemic after SAH Admission/1-3 days variables Complete case analysis Yes, Grid search Leave one out CV No - RF