Table 1.
Study | No. of femurs |
Lesion |
Mechanical test |
FEA |
Validation |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Type | Location | Meshing | Material | Parameter | R2 | ||||
Cheal et al., 1993 | 1 | Simulated | Neck | Compression | Geometry | Linear | Failure force | “poor” | |
Keyak et al., 2005a, Keyak et al., 2005b | 2005a | 24 | Real and simulated | Shaft | 4 point-bending | Voxel | Linear | Failure force | 0.88-0.95 |
2005b | 44 | Real | Proximal femur | Compression | Voxel | Nonlinear | Failure force | 0.83-0.88 | |
Spruijt et al., 2006 | 11 pairs | Simulated | Shaft | Torsion | Voxel | Linear | Failure moment | 0.68-0.82 | |
Tanck et al., 2009 | 5 pairs | Simulated | Proximal femur | Compression | Voxel | Nonlinear | Failure force | 0.92 | |
Derikx et al., 2012 | 10 pairs | Simulated | Proximal femur | Compression | Geometry | Nonlinear | Failure force | 0.90-0.93 | |
Alexander et al., 2013 | 8 pairs | Simulated | Neck | Compression | Geometry | Linear | NA | ||
Yosibash et al., 2014 | 7 pairs | Real | Proximal femur | Compression | Geometry | Linear | Yield force | 0.78 | |
Benca et al., 2019 | 16 pairs | Simulated | Neck | Compression | Voxel | Nonlinear | Failure force | 0.77-0.98 | |
Stiffness | 0.47-0.94 |
NA = Not Applicable.