Table 1.
Advantages | Limits | Potential interference in case of epidemic | |
---|---|---|---|
Home-based treatment | Makes it possible to limit exposure to the hospital setting |
Isolation. Acute intradialytic problems can be challenging |
Less exposure to the hospital milieu; links should be reinforced using telemedicine |
Remote counseling | A good way to avoid isolation; should integrate direct follow-up | Fragile and elderly patients may not be able to clearly explain their problems | May need to be increased during epidemics to avoid isolation. An “urgent pathway” has to be ensured |
Flexibility—empowerment | Patient empowerment is associated with better survival and better quality of life | Patient-designed dialysis may differ from prescriptions. This can be dangerous | Remote counseling should be reinforced, to avoid the introduction of subtle but important changes to prescriptions |
Biochemical controls at home | Practical, reduces the need for going to a laboratory or hospital | Standard pre- and post- dialysis controls may be difficult to organize | Care needs to be taken so that the frequency of controls is not reduced (except in acute epidemic phases) |
Family involvement | Can provide important psychological support | The burden may be heavy and create tension | Psychological aid could be needed, and would need to be reinforced in moments of crisis |
Residual kidney function | May be better preserved in tailored dialysis programs | Monitoring may be difficult to carry out, and slow loss of kidney function could go unnoticed | Particular attention needs to be paid if only remote monitoring is employed |
Assisted home dialysis | Allows limiting exposure to the hospital setting and eliminates travel time | May fail to guarantee privacy. The advantage of empowerment is usually lost | Aids are exposed to contagion and become potential carriers |
Reduction of travel time—lower carbon footprint | The ecologic advantages are debated, but are likely to be relevant especially if patients live far from the dialysis units | In some settings, the costs for the patients may be high. Waste management needs to be organized in advance | Limiting need to travel is an advantage in case of lockdown |
Other | The clinical results of home dialysis are usually at least competitive with hospital-based therapy | Home dialysis may be time consuming for the health care team, in particular if a personalized schedule is chosen | Delivering supplies may prove difficult to organize during lockdown; technical aid may be delayed. Home dialysis has to be a clear priority for technical aid and delivery of disposables |