Table 2. Studies of the microcirculation in animal models of CKD: heart.
First author | Year | Species (strain) | CKD model; CKD duration treatment | Main findings | Rarefaction [%] Compared with controls (method) | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Amann | 1992 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 14 months | HTN, left ventricular hypertrophy and MV rarefaction | 25% (stereological evaluation) | [26] |
Törnig | 1996 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks + antihypertensive treatment | No HTN; reduction in MV density was completely prevented by Moxonidine and in part by Ramipril | 22% (stereological evaluation) | [27] |
Amann | 1997 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) heart, M. psoas |
5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks | HTN; myocyte cross-sectional area and interstitial tissue increased, MV density reduced in the heart but unchanged in M. psoas | 23% in heart, none in M. psoas (stereological evaluation) | [24] |
Amann | 2000 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks ± Epo or Epo + antihypertensives (hydralazine+furosemide) | HTN; capillary rarefaction unchanged with Epo or Epo +antihypertensive treatment | 25% (stereological evaluation) | [34] |
Amann | 2000 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 15 weeks ± endothelin receptor antagonist or ACEi | HTN; MV density normalized with endothelin receptor antagonist, but not with ACEi | 17% (stereological evaluation) | [35] |
Amann | 2000 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks ± ACEi or bradykinin receptor antagonist or both | No HTN; ACEi, but not bradykinin receptor antagonist abrogated MV rarefaction | 29% (stereological evaluation) | [36] |
Amann | 2002 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for12 weeks ± α-Tocopherol (Vitamin E) | HTN; α-Tocopherol significantly attenuated MV rarefaction and interstitial fibrosis | 24% (stereological evaluation) | [37] |
Ogata | 2003 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks ± PTX or calcimimetic | HTN; treatment significantly attenuated MV rarefaction and interstitial fibrosis | 28% (stereological evaluation) | [39] |
Gross | 2005 | Spontaneously hypertensive stroke-prone rat (Wistar–Kyoto) | ½ NX; CKD for 12 weeks ± ovariectomy | HTN; significant improvement in MV density in ovariectomized rats treated with estrogens | n.a. (no controls without CKD) | [152] |
Koleganova | 2009 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 12 weeks (or 4 weeks) ± calcimimetic | HTN; treatment with a calcimimetic attenuated rarefaction and interstitial fibrosis | Approx. 28% (15% after 4 weeks) (stereological evaluation) | [38] |
Koleganova | 2009 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 12 weeks ± calcitriol | HTN; treatment with calcitriol ameliorated rarefaction and fibrosis | Approx. 25% (stereological evaluation) | [40] |
Tyralla | 2011 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks + 4 weeks antihypertensive treatment | HTN; treatment with ACEi, (but not with furosemide/hydralazine) improved myocardial fibrosis but not rarefaction | 10%; unchanged by antihypertensive treatment (stereological evaluation) | [41] |
Amann | 2011 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | (1) 5/6 NX; CKD for 8 weeks(2) 5/6 NX; CKD for 10 days ± renal denervation | No HTN; MV rarefaction prevented by renal denervation (after 10 days) | (1)18%;(2) 24% (stereological evaluation) | [33] |
DiMarco | 2011 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX; CKD for 14 days ± calcineurin inhibitor, hydralazine | HTN; treatment with calcineurin inhibitors, but not hydralazine, normalized MV density | ∼20% (lectin staining) | [42] |
Gut | 2013 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX CKD for 16 weeks ± Epo + enalapril | HTN; treatment normalized MV density, ameliorated myocardial fibrosis in 5/6 NX rats | −15% in 5/6 NX (methylene blue/basic fuchsin staining) | [47] |
Ali | 2014 | Rat (Wistar) | Adenine feeding (0.75%), 4 weeks ± gum acacia | HTN, myocardial hypertrophy, MV rarefaction ameliorated by treatment | Significantly decreased (with adenine; HE and PAS staining) | [50] |
Di Marco | 2015 | Rat (Spague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX ± sFlt-1 or VEGF121 infusion for 14 days (starting after NX) | HTN, MV density −15% in 5/6 NX treated with sFlt-1 and unchanged compared with sham-op. if treated with VEGF121 | (lectin staining) | [48] |
Golle | 2017 | Rat (Sprague–Dawley) | 5/6 NX CKD for 14 days, ± bone marrow-derived cells or their conditioned medium | MV density significantly decreased, restored by treatment | −20% (lectin staining) | [44] |
Prommer and Maurer | 2018 | Mouse (BALB/c) heart, M. cremaster | 5/6 NX; adenine feeding (0.2%) CKD for 4 months (5/6 NX) or for 4 weeks (adenine) | No HTN; loss of coherent MV networks, large avascular areas, diminished blood flow velocity, vascular tone, oxygen uptake. Rarefaction in the cremaster muscle paralleled rarefaction in the myocardium. Decrease in mRNA levels of HIF-1α, Angpt-2, TIE-1 and TIE-2, Flkt-1 and MMP-9 in the heart | Progressive rarefaction with increasing severity of CKD (serum urea levels). Mean: 34% (5/6 NX); 43% (adenine) | [18] |
Uchida | 2020 | Rat (Sprague−Dawley) | 5/6 NX CKD for 6 weeks + N-nitro-l-arginine (nitric oxide synthase inhibitor), ± enarodustat (prolyl-hydroxylase inhibitor,) | HTN; enarodustat restored capillary density in heart and kidneys, ameliorated myocardial fibrosis without change in HTN | Significantly decreased (mouse anti-aminopeptidase P monoclonal antibody) | [151] |