Table S5. Clinical outcomes.
Study | Mortality | Stroke | Spinal cord injury | Acute kidney injury | ICU stay [days] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Acute/emergent | |||||
Sun | 7 [5] | 4 [3] | 3 [2] | 1 [1] | NR |
Zhao | 1 [4] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Jakob | 22 [16] | 10 [7] | 6 [4] | NR | NR |
Shia | 3 [4] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | 4 [6] | NR |
Shia | 5 [6] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | 7 [8] | NR |
Shib | 2 [4] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | 4 [7] | NR |
Zhang | 5 [6] | 2 [2] | 0 [0] | 2 [2] | NR |
Katayama | 7 [6] | 4 [3] | 2 [2] | 4 [3] | NR |
Chen | 6 [27] | 0 [0] | NR | NR | 10±11 |
Chen | 3 [27] | 1 [9] | NR | NR | 12±12 |
Kobayashi | 5 [15] | 2 [6] | NR | NR | NR |
Aalaei-Andabili | 4 [17] | 2 [9] | 1 [4] | 6 [26] | 11±6* |
Hu | 8 [8] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | NR | 3±2 |
Shrestha | 11 [11] | 18 [18] | 1 [1] | 21 [21] | 6±5* |
Yamane | 2 [8] | 1 [4] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Berger | 2 [6] | 4 [13] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Goebel | 11 [15] | 2 [3] | 3 [4] | 18 [25] | 6±5* |
Lopez Almodovar | 2 [17] | 1 [8] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Ma | 19 [14] | 7 [5] | 0 [0] | 20 [15] | 8±4 |
Roselli | 3 [4] | 3 [4] | 3 [4] | 2 [3] | NR |
Kremer | 5 [15] | 3 [9] | 3 [9] | 23 [68] | 9±9 |
Lin | 3 [6] | 1 [2] | 0 [0] | 5 [9] | 4±4 |
Qian | 25 [11] | 2 [1] | 5 [2] | 35 [16] | 3±3 |
Tochii | 0 [0] | 4 [18] | 0 [0] | 2 [9] | 11±12 |
Yamamoto | 3 [3] | 4 [4] | 0 [0] | 6 [6] | NR |
Subtotal | 9.4 [7.4–11.9] | 4.7 [3.1–6.9] | 2.6 [1.9–3.7] | 10.5 [6.5–16.4] | 7 [5–8] |
Chronic/elective | |||||
Flores | 3 [12] | 4 [16] | 6 [24] | NR | NR |
Uchida | 1 [2] | 2 [3] | 2 [3] | 1 [2] | NR |
Sun | 2 [1] | 3 [2] | 4 [3] | 2 [1] | NR |
Jakob | 20 [14] | 7 [5] | 13 [9] | NR | NR |
Nakamura | NR | NR | 2 [4] | NR | NR |
Aalaei-Andabili | 4 [16] | 1 [4] | 1 [4] | 6 [24] | 13±9* |
Shrestha | 9 [11] | 11 [13] | 3 [4] | 16 [20] | 5±5* |
Shrestha | 3 [4] | 8 [12] | 0 [0] | 15 [22] | 7±8* |
Berger | 2 [6] | 2 [6] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Zhong | 2 [6] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Kremer | 5 [15] | 4 [12] | 2 [6] | 16 [47] | 9±9 |
Subtotal | 8.3 [5.2–12.8] | 7.2 [4.5–11.3] | 5 [2.8–8.8] | 14.5 [6.3–29.6] | 8 [5–11] |
Mixed | |||||
Leontyev | 4 [8] | 6 [12] | 10 [20] | 13 [25] | NR |
Weiss | 2 [7] | 3 [11] | 2 [7] | 8 [30] | 4±11* |
Mkalaluh | 5 [20] | 6 [24] | 1 [4] | 6 [24] | 11±11* |
Tsagakis | 32 [11] | 16 [6] | 14 [5] | 91 [32] | NR |
Alhussaini | 9 [19] | 3 [6] | 2 [4] | NR | NR |
Chu | 2 [5] | 3 [8] | 2 [5] | 1 [3] | 2±2* |
Dinato | 16 [20] | 4 [5] | 2 [3] | 38 [48] | NR |
Kozlov | 0 [0] | 1 [7] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Kozlov | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | 0 [0] | NR | NR |
Leone | 48 [17] | 25 [9] | 17 [6] | 55 [20] | 1±3* |
Zhang | 87 [11] | 36 [4] | 56 [7] | 263 [32] | 3±3 |
Subtotal | 13.1 [10.2–16.6] | 7.7 [5.4–10.7] | 6.5 [4.7–9] | 28.6 [22.3–35.8] | 3 [1–4] |
Overall | 10.2 [8.7–12] | 6.2 [5–7.8] | 4.1 [3.2–5.4] | 15.5 [11.9–20.1] | 6 [5–7] |
Data is presented as number of patients [%] or mean ± standard deviation. Aggregated subtotal and overall values are presented with 95% confidence intervals, using random-effects meta-analysis of proportions or means. *, mean and standard deviation recalculated using methods of Wan et al. a, DOI: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2013.10.058; b, DOI: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2014.02.077.