Table 3.
Evaluation of prediction equation accuracy in comparison with RMR measured by indirect calorimetry†
(Mean values and standard deviations; limits of agreement (LOA); percentages)
| REE (kcal/d) | Bias (P-M) | Slope (kcal/d per 100 kcal/d) | Intercept (kcal/d) | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | sd | Mean | sd | 95 % LOA (± 2 sd) | RMSE | Accurate predictions within ± 5 %‡ (%) | Accurate predictions within ± 10 %§ (%) | Underpredictionsǁ (%) | Overpredictions¶ (%) | Mean | sd | Mean | sd | |
| RMR measured | 1424 | 247 | ||||||||||||
| Harris–Benedict | 1502 | 162 | 78* | 157 | −229, 384 | 174 | 33⋅6 | 60⋅8 | 7⋅2 | 32⋅0 | −4⋅6* | 0⋅1 | 757* | 88 |
| Henry | 1432 | 202 | 8 | 163 | −311, 327 | 153 | 41⋅6 | 65⋅6 | 14⋅4 | 20⋅0 | −0⋅2* | 0⋅1 | 335* | 96 |
| Mifflin St–Jeor | 1424 | 180 | 0 | 153 | −300, 300 | 162 | 43⋅2 | 71⋅2 | 12⋅0 | 16⋅8 | −3⋅5* | 0⋅1 | 503* | 86 |
| Owen | 1303 | 131 | −121* | 165 | −443, 202 | 204 | 24⋅8 | 59⋅2 | 36⋅8 | 4⋅0 | −6⋅8* | 0⋅1 | 803* | 76 |
| Schofield | 1466 | 211 | 42* | 173 | −297, 381 | 177 | 29⋅6 | 63⋅2 | 13⋅6 | 23⋅2 | −1⋅8* | 0⋅5 | 313* | 83 |
REE, resting energy expenditure; P-M, predicted RMR minus measured RMR; RMSE, root-mean-square error calculated as √(Σ(actual RMR – predicted RMR)2)/n.
Mean value was significantly different from zero (P < 0⋅05).
To convert kcal to kJ, multiply by 4·184.
Percentage of participants with predicted RMR within 5 % of measured RMR.
Percentage of participants with predicted RMR within 10 % of measured RMR.
Percentage of participants with predicted RMR being more than 10 % below measured RMR.
Percentage of participants with predicted RMR being more than 10 % above measured RMR.