Table 3 –
Language scores for the participant groups and the results of the between-group statistical comparisons (right-most column)
| Measures | Healthy Mean (SD) [95% CI] |
PPA Mean (SD) [95% CI] |
MCI Mean (SD) [95% CI] |
AD Mean (SD) [95% CI] |
ANOVA F p |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fluency | |||||
| Average WPM | 141.73 (39.51) [126.09 – 157.37] |
76.91 (39.50)a, b [61.88 – 91.94] |
123.76 (31.21) [106.63 – 140.90] |
116.61 (42.81) [99.47 – 133.74] |
F(3,86) = 12.61 p < .001* |
| Total Disfluencies | 9.46 (7.10) [3.98 – 14.93] |
27.57 (19.17)a, b [22.32 – 32.83] |
10.50 (9.26) [4.50 – 16.50] |
12.90 (13.88) [6.90 – 18.90] |
F(3,86) = 9.71 p < .001* |
| Word Retrieval | |||||
| MATTR | .86 (.03) [.84 – .88] |
.83 (.08) [.81 – .85] |
.86 (.04) [.84 – .88] |
.87 (.04) [.84 – .80] |
F(3,86) = 2.20 p = .093 |
| Idea Density | .41 (.04) [.38 – .43] |
.39 (.08) [.37 – .42] |
.39 (.04) [.36 – .42] |
.40 (.06) [.37 – .43] |
F(3,86) = .27 p = .870 |
| Proportion CIUs | .82 (.10) [.75 – .87] |
.63 (.20)a, b [.57 – .68] |
.80 (.12) [.74 – .87] |
.72 (.18) [.65 – .78] |
F(3,86) = 6.88 p < .001* |
| No. Semantic Errors | .00 (.00) [−.24 – .24] |
.46 (.81) [.22–.70] |
.00 (.00) [−.27 – .27] |
.25 (.91) [−.02 – .52 |
F(3,86) = 3.18 p = .028 |
| No. Phonological Errors | .04 (.20) [−.24 – .33] |
.69 (1.28) [.41 – .97] |
.00 (.00) [−.31 – .31] |
.05 (.22) [−.26 – .36] |
F(3,86) = 5.35 p = .002* |
| Total Word Retrieval Errors | .04 (.20) [−.38 – .46] |
1.23 (1.75)a, b [.82 – 1.63] |
.00 (.00) [−.46 – .46] |
.30 (.92) [−.26 – .76] |
F(3,86) = 7.37 p < .001* |
| Syntax | |||||
| MLU, morphemes | 9.93 (2.13) [8.70 – 11.16] |
9.85 (3.81) [8.60 – 11.03] |
11.05 (2.94) [9.70 – 12.39] |
9.67 (2.85) [8.32 – 11.02] |
F(3,86) = .87 p = .458 |
| Proportion grammatical utterances | .89 (.16) [.80 – .96] |
.66 (.28)a, b [.58 – .73] |
.89 (.12) [.79 – .97] |
.82 (.18) [.73 – .91] |
F(3,86) = 6.92 p < .001* |
| Verbs/utterance | 1.22 (.27) [1.03 – 1.41] |
1.40 (.68) [1.21 – 1.58] |
1.30 (.35) [1.08 – 1.51] |
1.23 (.44) [1.02 – 1.42] |
F(3,86) = .69 p = .557 |
| Complex Utterances | .47 (1.02) [.17 – .74] |
.08 (.27) [−.19 – .35] |
.60 (.75) [.28 – .91] |
.35 (.58) [.03 – .66] |
F(3,86) = 2.30 p = .083 |
| Total Morphological Errors | .04 (.20) [−.21 – .29] |
.50 (.99) [.25 – .74] |
.05 (.22) [−.22 – .32] |
.20 (.61) [−.07 – .47] |
F(3,86) = 2.88 p = .040 |
| General | |||||
| Total Errors | 9.54 (7.16) [3.87 – 15.20] |
29.31 (19.79)a, b [23.86 – 34.74] |
10.55 (9.23) [4.34 – 16.75] |
13.40 (14.77) [7.19 – 19.60] |
F(3,86) = 10.82 p < .001* |
Abbreviations: AD= Alzheimer’s Dementia, CIU = correct information units, MATTR = moving average type-token ratio, PPA= Primary Progressive Aphasia, MCI= Mild Cognitive Impairment, WPM = words per minute,
p < .003,
Post-hoc comparison with healthy group, p < .05,
Post-hoc comparison with MCI, p < .05