Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 22;10:10015. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-66529-1

Table 1.

Nested mixed effects models for the two dependent variables inclusion of other in the self (IOS) and likeability of the virtual other (LIKE) investigating the effects of the independent variables synchrony, musical pattern (i.e., cultural familiarity), and enjoyment of the music. Every model includes the random effect (1 | participant). The Akaike information criterion (AIC), Bayesian information criterion (BIC), marginal R2 (variance explained by fixed effects only), and conditional R2 (variance explained by fixed and random effects) are provided. χ2 and p values refer to model comparisons to the previous model (unless stated otherwise) using likelihood ratio tests. Null model: IOS ~ (1 | participant). Best fitting models are marked in bold letters.

Dependent variable: IOS; Independent variables: Synchrony, Musical Pattern, Enjoyment of Music
Model AIC BIC Marginal R2 Conditional R2 Improvement in Model Fit
χ2(1) p
IOS Null Model 2235 2246 0.338
IOS ~ Synchrony 2059 2073 0.310 0.750 178.52 <0.001
IOS ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern 2047 2064 0.324 0.767 14.35 <0.001
IOS ~ Synchrony × Musical Pattern 2049 2069 0.323 0.766 0 0.999
IOS ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern + Enjoyment 2035 2056 0.356 0.770 13.17° <0.001°
IOS ~ Synchrony × Enjoyment + Musical Pattern 2028 2052 0.364 0.781 9.61 0.002
Dependent variable: LIKE; Independent variables: Synchrony, Musical Pattern, Enjoyment of Music
Model AIC BIC Marginal R2 Conditional R2 Improvement in Model Fit
χ2(1) p
LIKE Null Model 2097 2108 0.299
LIKE ~ Synchrony 2007 2020 0.210 0.577 92.87 <0.001
LIKE ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern 1977 1994 0.260 0.642 31.66 <0.001
LIKE ~ Synchrony × Musical Pattern 1978 1999 0.260 0.642 0.36 0.551
LIKE ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern + Enjoyment 1934 1955 0.398 0.655 44.38^ <0.001^
LIKE ~ Synchrony × Enjoyment + Musical Pattern 1935 1960 0.399 0.656 1.06 0.304

°As compared to model IOS ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern.

^As compared to model LIKE ~ Synchrony + Musical Pattern.