DNA |
No handling of infectious material
Can be used in immunocompromised subjects
Reasonable and enduring immune response, both humoral and cell-mediated
No anti-plasmid immune responses allowing for effective boosting (reported by Inovio)
Rapid and scalable manufacturing
Long-term stability
Options for multivalent formulation
Oral formulation possible (Symvivo)
|
No approved DNA vaccines, along with real-world experience in the global population
Variable mucosal immunity and other immune responses
Some require special tools for delivery to the sub-dermal layer (Inovio)
Potential risk for host cell genomic integration (though likely small for plasmids)
|
RNA |
Rapid design and production
No handling of infectious material
No potential for insertional mutagenesis
Strong early antiviral responses, both humoral and cell-mediated
Options for multivalent formulation
Scaling up to global-wide production appears feasible but not yet tested
|
No approved RNA vaccines, but some clinical testing for other viruses (rabies, influenza)
Inflammatory reactions possible
Most formulations require a cold chain for longevity and stability
Ubiquitous ribonucleases require careful design with substituted nucleosides and skilled formulation of lipid nanoparticle carriers for effective delivery
Boosting likely necessary to achieve robust and long-lasting immunity
|
Protein |
No handling of infectious material
Strong antibody responses
Precedent for successful vaccines of this platform
Viral protein complexes can be formulated to simulate virus patterning (VLPs)
|
|
Viral Vector (both replicating/non-replicating) |
Years of experience in the gene therapy field studying safety, immune responses
Strong antibody and cellular responses
|
Risk for chromosomal integration and oncogenesis
Cannot be used in immunocompromised subjects
Preexisting antibodies to some vectors possible
Potential for inflammatory AEs
Variable immunogenicity
Significant manufacturing hurdles at scale
|
Live Virus (attenuated) |
Proven technology
Strong immune response
Multivalent
Simple formulation, not requiring adjuvants
Proven track record for economical large-scale manufacturing
|
Requires dedicated biosafety level facilities
Risk for attenuated virus to regain virulence
Can be complicated to scale up manufacturing
|
Virus (inactivated) |
|
|