Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 6;70(5):748–753. doi: 10.1093/cid/ciz281

Table 1.

Multiple Influenza Challenge Exposure Timing and Outcomes

Participant (Sex, Age, y) Challenge Date Viral Dose (TCID50) Nasal Viral Detection (Duration, d) Days of Symptoms No. of Symptoms Severity Scorea D0 and W8 HAI Titerb D0 and W8 NAI Titerb D0 and W8 HA Stalk Titerb PBL Gene Expressionc
Challenge 1
 1 (F, 21) 9 Oct 2012 106 + (4) 5 11 55 0–40 0–1280 44 084–80 480 +
 2 (M, 19) 25 Sept 2012 106 – (0) 6 1 6 10–10 1280–2560 NA
 3 (M, 24) 21 Jan 2013 107 + (1) 8 6 48 20–160 160–2560 43 048–58 892 +
 4 (M, 21) 19 Mar 2013 107 – (0) 2 1 2 0–160 2560–1280 65 165–81 987 +
 5 (F, 24) 2 Apr 2013 107 + (7) 11 12 132 0–40 0–80 27 422–86 008 +
 6 (F, 24) 10 Dec 2012 106 – (0) 6 2 12 0–80 80–160 NA
 7 (F, 28) 5 Jun 2012 103 – (0) 1 2 2 0–10 0–40 NA NA
Challenge 2
 1 (F, 22) 15 Oct 2013 107 + (2) 0 0 0 10–80 80–640 60 221–83 250 +
 2 (M, 21) 15 Oct 2013 107 + (1) 0 0 0 0–80 640–2560 42 016–96 331
 3 (M, 24) 12 Nov 2013 107 + (1) 11 5 55 160–160 1280–1280 86 034–67 954 +
 4 (M, 21) 12 Nov 2013 107 – (0) 4 3 12 10–20 1280–1280 NA
 5 (F, 24) 12 Nov 2013 107 – (0) 4 5 20 20–80 320–320 54 703–55 000
 6 (F, 25) 12 Nov 2013 107 – (0) 5 3 15 40–160 80–80 24 681–22 228
 7 (F, 30) 9 Dec 2013 107 + (6) 7 8 56 0–10 0–320 18 486–60 623 NA

Abbreviations: –, negative; +, positive; D0, prechallenge baseline day 0; F, female; HA, hemagglutinin; HAI, hemagglutination inhibition; M, male; NA, not available for testing; NAI, neuraminidase inhibition; PBL, peripheral blood leukocyte; TCID50, 50% tissue culture infectious dose; W8, 8 weeks after challenge.

aMean and median symptom scores across both challenge trials were 35.5 and 10, respectively. Severity scores ranged from 0 to 750. Symptom scores represent the totality of the disease experienced after challenge.

bSerum antibody titers against the hemagglutinin head, NAI, and HA stalk were measured at D0 and at W8.

cPeripheral blood leukocyte expression of antiviral and immune-related genes is shown in Figure 1.