Table 3. Complete responder scenarios.
Four patient scenarios, and six interventions per scenario considered for complete PPI responders. Rankings from the entire group, surgeon subset and therapeutic GI (iGI) subset are displayed. Each cell displays ranking for appropriateness [% agreement, median (min-max)]. Cells shaded green indicate agreement as an appropriate intervention, red indicate agreement as an inappropriate intervention, and white indicate lack of agreement and/or uncertain appropriateness.
| Scenario | All Experts | Surgeons Subset | iGI Subset | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OMT | LF | MSA | TIF | TIFCR | RFED | OMT | LF | MSA | TIF | TIFCR | RFED | OMT | LF | MSA | TIF | TIFCR | RFED | |
| Heartburn, + Sig Hernia |
60%, 7 (1-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
0%,
1 (1-2) |
60%, 7 (1-9) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
50%, 6.5 (1-9) |
100%,
9 (9-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
0%,
1 (1-8) |
38%, 5.5 (1-8) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
71%, 7 (5-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
100%,
8 (7-9) |
0%,
1 (1-2) |
86%,
7 (5-9) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
| Regurigtation, + Sig Hernia |
40%, 5 (1-9) |
100%,
9 (9-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
0%,
1 (1-2) |
60%, 7 (1-9) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
25%, 5 (1-9) |
100%,
9 (9-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
38%, 5.5 (1-8) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
57%, 7 (1-9) |
100%,
9 (9-9) |
100%,
9 (8-9) |
0%,
1 (1-2) |
86%,
7 (3-9) |
0%,
1 (1-1) |
| Heartburn, No Sig Hernia |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
93%,
9 (6-9) |
100%,
8 (7-9) |
87%,
8 (6-9) |
40%, 6 (1-9) |
40%, 6 (2-9) |
100%,
9 (8-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
75%, 7.5 (6-9) |
50%, 6.5 (1-8) |
25%, 6 (3-9) |
100%,
8 (7-9) |
86%,
7 (6-9) |
100%,
7 (7-9) |
100%,
8 (7-9) |
29%, 5 (1-9) |
57%, 7 (2-9) |
| Regurgitations, No Sig Hernia |
60%, 9 (2-9) |
87%,
9 (6-9) |
93%,
9 (6-9) |
80%,
8 (6-9) |
40%, 6 (1-8) |
33%, 6 (1-8) |
63%, 9 (4-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
100%,
9 (7-9) |
75%, 7.5 (6-9) |
50%, 6.5 (1-8) |
25%, 6 (1-8) |
57%, 8 (2-9) |
71%, 8 (6-9) |
86%,
7 (6-9) |
867%,
8 (6-9) |
29%, 5 (1-8) |
43%, 5 (1-8) |
Optimization of medical therapy (OMT); Laparoscopic fundoplication (LF); Magnetic sphincter augmentation (MSA); Transoral incisionless fundoplication (TIF); TIF with crural repair (TIFCR); Radiofrequency energy delivery (RFED)