Table 2.
Measurement | No. | Severe Group, Estimated Marginal Mean (95% CI) |
No. | Moderate Group, Estimated Marginal Mean (95% CI) |
P Valuea |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Weight change, kg | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -10.0 (-13.3 to -6.6)b | 31 | -6.0 (-9.7 to -2.4)b | <0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -8.0 (-11.7 to -4.4)b | 31 | -4.9 (-8.9 to -0.9)b | 0.008 |
Weight change, % of baseline | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -11.2 (-14.9 to -7.6)b | 31 | -6.7 (-10.7 to -2.7)b | <0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -9.0 (-12.9 to -5.1)b | 31 | -5.5 (-9.8 to -1.2)f | 0.012 |
Body mass index change, kg/m2c | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -3.79 (-5.08 to -2.49)b | 31 | -2.25 (-3.67 to -0.84)b | 0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -2.94 (-4.37 to -1.51)b | 31 | -1.61 (-3.17 to -0.04)e | 0.007 |
Lean tissues | |||||
Whole-body lean mass change, kgd | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -2.9 (-3.9 to -1.9)b | 31 | -1.9 (-3.1 to -0.8)b | 0.02 |
36 mo | 41 | -2.8 (-3.9 to -1.6)b | 31 | -2.0 (-3.2 to -0.7)b | 0.04 |
Muscle strength change, kg | |||||
Dominant hand | |||||
24 mo | 44 | -1.91 (-3.70 to -0.13)e | 31 | -3.21 (-5.24 to -1.18)b | 0.16 |
36 mo | 41 | -2.25 (-4.02 to -0.47)f | 31 | -4.20 (-6.12 to -2.28)b | 0.03 |
Non-dominant hand | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -2.33 (-4.09 to -0.58)f | 31 | -3.07 (-5.04 to -1.11)b | 0.30 |
36 mo | 41 | -2.80 (-4.68 to -0.91)b | 31 | -2.81 (-4.84 to -0.77)f | 0.92 |
Bone mineral density, g/cm2d | |||||
Total hip change | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -0.030 (-0.046 to -0.015)b | 30 | -0.007 (-0.025 to 0.011) | <0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -0.038 (-0.054 to -0.021)b | 30 | -0.019 (-0.038 to -0.001)e | 0.02 |
Femoral neck change | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -0.046 (-0.067 to -0.025)b | 30 | -0.039 (-0.063 to 0.015)b | 0.36 |
36 mo | 41 | -0.063 (-0.085 to -0.040)b | 30 | -0.045 (-0.070 to -0.020)b | 0.047 |
Lumbar spine change | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -0.046 (-0.065 to -0.028)b | 31 | -0.042 (-0.063 to -0.021)b | 0.31 |
36 mo | 41 | -0.044 (-0.065 to -0.022)b | 31 | -0.048 (-0.073 to -0.024)b | 0.77 |
Whole-body change | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -0.015 (-0.041 to 0.011) | 31 | -0.005 (-0.035 to 0.026) | 0.06 |
36 mo | 41 | -0.021 (-0.051 to 0.008) | 31 | 0.002 (-0.031 to 0.036) | 0.007 |
Fat mass and distribution | |||||
Waist circumference change, cm | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -9.4 (-12.7 to -6.2)b | 31 | -5.1 (-8.8 to -1.5)f | <0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -7.4 (-10.8 to -3.9)b | 31 | -4.3 (-8.1 to -0.4)e | 0.04 |
Hip circumference change, cm | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -6.6 (-9.1 to -4.2)b | 31 | -4.7 (-7.4 to -1.9)b | 0.005 |
36 mo | 41 | -5.9 (-8.5 to -3.2)b | 31 | -4.4 (-7.3 to -1.5)b | 0.046 |
Ratio of waist to hip circumference changeg | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -0.020 (-0.062 to 0.022) | 31 | 0.003 (-0.043 to 0.050) | 0.02 |
36 mo | 41 | -0.030 (-0.075 to 0.014) | 31 | 0.006 (-0.042 to 0.054) | 0.005 |
Whole-body fat mass change, kgd | |||||
24 mo | 45 | -5.9 (-8.1 to -3.7)b | 31 | -3.3 (-5.8 to -0.9)f | <0.001 |
36 mo | 41 | -4.8 (-6.9 to -2.6)b | 31 | -3.1 (-5.6 to -0.7)f | 0.001 |
Abdominal adipose tissue change, cm3 | |||||
Subcutaneous | |||||
24 mo | 40 | -2341 (-3161 to -1520)b | 29 | -1551 (-2454 to -647)b | 0.01 |
36 mo | 35 | -1986 (-2900 to -1072)b | 26 | -1477 (-2504 to -451)f | 0.16 |
Visceral | |||||
24 mo | 40 | -1647 (-2199 to -1094)b | 30 | -999 (-1594 to -403)b | 0.001 |
36 mo | 35 | -1287 (-1868 to -705)b | 26 | -866 (-1502 to -229)f | 0.03 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; mo, months; TEMPO, Type of Energy Manipulation for Promoting optimum metabolic health and body composition in Obesity.
Bolded P values in the right-hand column represent P values that are less than 0.05.
P values for comparison between the severe and moderate interventions at each time point.
P < 0.001 versus baseline for that group. For within-group comparisons between follow-up and baseline values, a repeated-measures linear mixed model was used.
Calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared.
Measured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry.
P < 0.05 versus baseline for that group. For within-group comparisons between follow-up and baseline values, a repeated-measures linear mixed model was used.
P < 0.01 versus baseline for that group. For within-group comparisons between follow-up and baseline values, a repeated-measures linear mixed model was used.
Calculated as waist circumference divided by hip circumference.