Table 1.
Study ID | Author | Date | Technology |
Sampling rate (Hz) |
Experimental setup |
Trial duration (min) |
Cohort |
Sample size |
Age (y) |
Box size |
N |
PD state* |
PD score** |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Marmelat | 2018 | Footswitches | 1,942 | Overground | 15 | Healthy young | 15 | 23 (1.69) | 10–N/8 | 512 | ||
1 | Marmelat | 2018 | Footswitches | 1,942 | Overground | 15 | Healthy old | 14 | 67.71 (5.92) | 11–N/8 | 512 | ||
1 | Marmelat | 2018 | Footswitches | 1,942 | Overground | 15 | Patients with PD | 13 | 71.31 (6.12) | 12–N/8 | 512 | ON | 1.64 (0.69) |
2 | Dotov | 2017 | IMU | 128 | Overground | 3 | Patients with PD | 19 | 60.8 (10.6) | 4–N/4 | 120–195 | ON | 2 (1–3) |
2 | Dotov | 2017 | IMU | 128 | Overground | 3 | Healthy old | 19 | 60.8 (10.6) | 4–N/4 | 120–195 | ||
3 | Stout | 2016 | Motion capture | 200 | Treadmill | 15 | Healthy young | 10 | 25.2 (1.5) | 16–N/9 | 652 | ||
3 | Stout | 2016 | Motion capture | 200 | Treadmill | 15 | Healthy old | 10 | 59.6 (10.7) | 16–N/9 | 719 | ||
4 | Kosse | 2016 | iPod touch | 88–92 | Overground | 3 | Healthy young | 29 | 28 (7) | 17–N/7 | — | ||
4 | Kosse | 2016 | iPod touch | 88–92 | Overground | 3 | Healthy old | 30 | 62 (8) | 17–N/7 | — | ||
5 | Chien | 2015 | Motion capture | 100 | Treadmill | 5 | Healthy young | 10 | 27 (4) | 4–N/4 | 200 | ||
5 | Chien | 2015 | Motion capture | 100 | Treadmill | 5 | Healthy old | 7 | 70 (10) | 4–N/4 | 200 | ||
6 | Ota | 2014 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2–4 | Patients with PD | 45 | 69.8 (8.2) | 10–N/2 | 154 | ON | 1–3 |
6 | Ota | 2014 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2–4 | Healthy old | 17 | 70.2 (2.8) | 10–N/2 | 154 | ||
7 | Kobsar | 2014 | IMU | 100 | Overground | 10 | Healthy young | 41 | 24 (3) | 4–N/2 | 1,000 | ||
7 | Kobsar | 2014 | IMU | 100 | Overground | 10 | Healthy old | 41 | 76 (5) | 4–N/2 | 1,024 | ||
8 | Kaipust | 2013 | Motion capture | 100 | Treadmill | 6 | Healthy young | 27 | 25.7 (3.0) | — | 151 | ||
8 | Kaipust | 2013 | Motion capture | 100 | Treadmill | 6 | Healthy old | 27 | 71.4 (4.4) | — | 151 | ||
9 | Bartsch | 2007 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2 | Healthy old | 24 | 64.3 (1.3) | N/10 s length | ~120 | ||
9 | Bartsch | 2007 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2 | Patients with PD | 29 | 67 (1.3) | N/10 s length | ~120 | ON | — |
10 | Warlop | 2006 | IMU | 512 | Overground | 10 | Patients with PD | 20 | 65.3 (9.6) | 10–N/2 | 512 | ON | 2 (1–3) |
10 | Warlop | 2006 | IMU | 512 | Overground | 10 | Healthy old | 15 | 60.1 (13.3) | 10–N/2 | 512 | ||
11 | Toledo | 2005 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2 | Patients with PD | 36 | 61.2 (9.0) | — | — | — | |
11 | Toledo | 2005 | Foot switches | 100 | Overground | 2 | Healthy old | 30 | 57.7 (7.0) | — | — | ||
12 | Malatesta | 2003 | Foot switches | 100 | Treadmill | 6 | Healthy old | 10 | 65.3 (2.5) | 10–20 | — | ||
12 | Malatesta | 2003 | Foot switches | 100 | Treadmill | 6 | Healthy young | 10 | 24.6 (2.6) | 10–20 | — | ||
13 | Hausdorff | 2000 | Foot switches | 300 | Overground | 5 | Patients with PD | 15 | 47 (29–71) | 10–20 | — | ON | 1–4 |
13 | Hausdorff | 2000 | Foot switches | 300 | Overground | 5 | Healthy old | 16 | 67 (44–80) | 10–20 | — | ||
14 | Hausdorff | 1997 | Foot switches | 300 | Overground | 6 | Healthy old | 10 | 75.7 (3.2) | 10–20 | 316 | ||
14 | Hausdorff | 1997 | Foot switches | 300 | Overground | 6 | Healthy young | 22 | 24.6 (1.9) | 10–20 | 315 |
Reported as mean (standard deviation) or median (lower limit–higher limit).
“—” indicates not reported.
Medication state.
Hoehn and Yahr scale.