Skip to main content
. 2020 May 26;11:1015. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01015

TABLE 1.

Selected studies that assess the effects of cognitive-motor interference on long-term memory.

Authors Age (years) Number Intervention type Memory task & test Retention interval Comparison conditions Results
Arousal and Neuropsychological Theories
Soga et al., 2017 22 20 Cycling (12 min) Moderate intensity 60–70% HRmax Visual source memory task Retrieval 5 min Within subject DTCs1 lower item recognition accuracy
Frith et al., 2017 22 88 Treadmill running (15 min) Vigorous (RPE 16-20) Auditory Verbal Learning Task Prospective Memory 20 min 24 h Control Pre-3 encoding Post-4 encoding 20 min: Free call Pre3 > SIM/ Control 24 h: Recognition Pre > SIM/ After
Sng et al., 2018 23 88 Treadmill walking (15 min) Preferred pace Moderate intensity 58% HRmax Auditory Verbal Learning Test Prospective memory 20 min 24 h Control Pre- encoding Post- encoding 20 min: Free recall Pre > SIM & Post Control > Post 24 h: Recognition Pre > SIM & Post Attribution Pre > Post Control > Post
Tomporowski et al., 2017 22 24 Isometric hand grip (100 s) 50%max/10%max Visual word list Free recall Recognition Immediate Delayed (5 min) Within subject DTCs during encoding: Lower word recall & recognition
Attention Theories
Lindenberger et al., 2000 60–70 40–50 20–30 47
45
48
Walking (170 s) (Simple/Complex) Auditory word list Serial recall 10 s Standing Sitting DTCs increased with age DTCs in young
Li et al., 2001 60–75 20–30 40
37
Walking (Adapted speed/ Complexity) Auditory word list Serial recall 10-s Single task DTCs increased with age
Epling et al., 2016 28 12 Vigorous running (5 min) (Adapted speed) Auditory word list Free recall Immediate Single task DTCs for words
Green and Helton, 2011 22 12 Traverse wall climbing (3 min) Auditory word list Free recall Immediate Single task (Seated) DTCs for words
Darling and Helton, 2014 27 12 Traverse wall climb (5 min) Auditory word list Free recall Immediate Single task (Seated) DTCs for words
Cognitive Energetic Theories
Toumpaniari et al., 2015 4–5 67 Animal imitation Gesture Verbal repetition Visual word-pair list Cued recall 4 weeks Seated SIM2 > Gesture > Seated
Mavilidi et al., 2016 4–5 87 Animal imitation movement to spatial locations (30 min) Running (30 min) Object name-location paired association Name- location recall Immediate 5 weeks Seated observation Immediate: SIM = Run > Seated Delayed: SIM = Run > Seated
Mavilidi et al., 2017 4–5 86 Running to spatial locations (10 min) Running (undirected) (10 min) Object name-location paired association Name-location recall Recognition Immediate 6 weeks Seated observation Immediate + delayed: SIM > Run > Seated
Mavilidi et al., 2018a 4–5 120 Running, jumping, skipping along spatial number line (15 min) Running (15 min) Counting Number line estimation Block counting Numerical magnitude comparison Numerical identification Immediate 6 weeks Seated observation Control Immediate + delayed: IPA5 > NIPA6
Schmidt et al., 2019 8–10 104 Animal imitation Verbal repetition Auditory-Visual word-pair list Cued recall Immediate Seated IPA5 & NIPA6 > Seated
Entrainment & Embodied Learning Theories
Schmidt-Kassow et al., 2013 22 81 Cycling (30 min) 69% HRmax Auditory word list Cued recall 48 h Seated rest Pre exercise SIM > Rest/Pre
Schmidt-Kassow et al., 2014, Exp #1 Exp #2 22 22 18 31 Treadmill (30 min) Light intensity Treadmill (30 min) Light intensity Auditory word list Cued recall Auditory word list Cued recall 24 h 24 h Within subject Within subject SIM > Rest SIM > Rest

DTCs1 = Dual-Task Costs; SIM2 = Simultaneous; Pre3 = Exercise prior encoding; Post4 = Exercise after encoding; IPA5 = Integrated physical activity; and NIPA6 = Nonintegrated physical activity.