Table 1. Baseline demographic and clinical characteristics of study participants.
Author | Year | Research types | No. of participants (% women) | Mean age [year]* | Etiology of PAH | WHO functional class | PAH medications used | Baseline PeakVO2
(mL/min/kg)* |
Baseline 6-minute walk distance (m)* |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mereles et al. | 2006 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 15; control: 15; women: 66.7% | 50 [13] | 80% IPAH; 20% CTEPH | 20% Class II; 73%Class III | ERA: 63%; PD5-I: 33% | Ex T: 13.2 (3.1); Control: 11.9 (3.1) | Ex T: 439 [82]; Control: 411 [86] |
Ley et al. | 2013 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 10; control: 10; women: 70% | 50 [11] | 55% IPAH; 20% CTEPH; 10% CTD |
20% Class II; 80% Class III | Mono: 25%; Dual: 60%; Triple: 15% | NA | Ex T: 449 [80]; Control: 423 [101] |
Chan et al. | 2013 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 10; control: 13; women: 100% | 54 [10] | 22% IPAH; 74% CTD; 4% drug induced | 91% Class II/III | Mono: 30%; Dual: 26%; Triple:39% | Ex T: 17.6 (5.7); Control: 14.7 (5.1) | Ex T: 411 [73]; Control: 377 [97] |
Saglam et al. | 2015 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 14; control: 15; women: 80.6% | 50 [12] | 26% IPAH; 23% CHD; 51% CTD | 52% Class II; 48% Class III | ERA: 32%; PD5-I: 10%; CCB: 16% | NA | Ex T: 427 [98]; Control: 357 [137] |
Ehlken et al. | 2015 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 38; control: 41; women: 54% | 56 [12] | 71% PAH; 29% CTEPH | 16% Class II; 76% Class III; 5% Class IV | Mono: 31%; Dual: 48%; Triple: 11.5% | Ex T: 13.3 (3.6); Control: 12.7 (4.0) | Ex T: 453 [91]; Control: 413 [95] |
Laura González-Saiz et al. | 2017 | Randomized controlled trial | Ex T: 20; control: 20; women: 60% | 46 [11] | 38% IPAH; 10% CTEPH; 8% CHD; 15% CTD |
63% Class II; 14% Class III | Mono:40%; Combi: 37.5%; Mono + PGI: 25%; Combi + PGI: 17.5% | Ex T: 15.7 (3.3); Control: 19.8 (6.5) | Ex T: 500 [70]; Control: 546 [99] |
Shigefumi Fukui et al. | 2016 | Non-randomized control trial | Ex T: 17; control: 24; women: 73% | 68 [9] | 100% CTEPH | 85% Class II; 12% Class III | Drug:61% | Ex T: 17.4 (2.6) Control: 17.8 (2.6) |
Ex T: 498 [96]; Control:468 [102] |
Martínez-Quintana et al. | 2010 | Non-randomized control trial | Ex T: 4; control: 4; women: 62.5% | 28 [6] | 100% CHD | NA | ERA:87.5% | NA | Ex T: 364 [50]; Control:442 [193] |
Fox et al. | 2011 | Non-randomized control trial | Ex T: 11; control: 11; women: 68% | 52 [19] | 45% IPAH; 9% CTEPH; 5% CHD; 41% CTD | NA | ERA: 63%; PD5-I: 45%; Mono: 54%; Combi: 45% | Ex T: 8.2 (1.9); Control: 11.6 (5.5) | Ex T: 353 [60]; Control:425 [80] |
Grünig et al. | 2012 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 21; women: 95% | 52 [18] | 100% CTD | 43% Class II; 33% Class III | Mono: 38%; Dual: 48%; Triple: 14% | Ex T: 11.8 (3.4) | Ex T: 386 [121] |
Grünig et al. | 2012 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 183; women: 69% | 53 [15] | 45% IPAH; 17% CTEPH; 8% CHD; 10% CTD |
14% Class II; 75% Class III | ERA: 59%; PD5-I: 58%; Mono: 44%; Combi: 51% | Ex T: 12.2 (3.5) | Ex T: 425 [106] |
Nagel et al. | 2012 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 35; women: 46% | 61 [15] | 100% CTEPH | 20% Class II; 74% Class III | ERA: 60%; PD5-I: 60%; Mono: 49%; Combi: 46% | Ex T: 12.1 (1.7) | Ex T: 408 [108] |
Becker-Grünig et al. | 2013 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 20; women: 80% | 48 [11] | 100% CHD | 30% Class II; 70% Class III | ERA: 70%; PD5-I: 60% | Ex T: 11.4 (2.2) | Ex T: 423 [90] |
Kabitz et al. | 2014 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 7; women: 57% | 60 [11] | 72% IPAH; 28% CTD | 86% Class III; 14% Class IV | ERA: 28%; PD5-I: 86% | NA | Ex T: 417 [51] |
Grünig et al. | 2011 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 58; women: 72% | 51 [12] | 64% IPAH; 10% CTEPH; 2% CHD; 4% CTD |
17% Class II; 76% Class III | Mono: 66%; Dual: 31%; Triple: 3% | Ex T: 12.5 (3.0) | Ex T: 440 [90] |
Inagaki et al. | 2014 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 8; women: 100% | 64 [12] | 100% CTEPH | 75% Class II; 25% Class III | ERA: 38%; PD5-I: 62%; Mono: 62%; Combi: 38% | NA | Ex T: 383 [91] |
De man et al. | 2009 | Pre-post intervention study | Ex T: 19; women: 79% | 42 [13] | 100% IPAH | NA | Mono: 42%; Combi: 58% | Ex T: 15 (4.0) | Ex T: 496 [108] |
*, data are shown as mean (SD).