Skip to main content
. 2020 May;12(5):2691–2705. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2020.03.69

Table S1. Inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria.

Author Year Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Mereles et al. 2006 • Severe chronic pulmonary hypertension, receiving targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥3 months
• WHO-FC II–IV
• No recent syncope or skeletal muscle disorder
Those who do not meet the inclusion criteria
Ley et al. 2013 • Age ≥18 years
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition≥3 months
• WHO-FC II–III
• No recent syncope, no skeletal muscle disorder
• Age ≤18 years old
• WHO-FC Class I or IV
• Other factors that do not meet the inclusion criteria
Chan et al. 2013 • WHO group I PAH
• Diagnosis of resting mPAP ≥25 mmHg by right heart catheter
• The condition is stable ≥3 months, and has not participated in pulmonary rehabilitation training for nearly 6 months
• WHO-FC Class I or IV
• FEV1/FVC ≤65%
• EF <40%, PCWP ≥18 mmHg
• Serious mental illness
• severe liver and kidney dysfunction, metabolic abnormalities
• History of ischemic heart disease
• Use of exercise-restrictive drugs, antivirals, drugs, smoking, pregnancy
Ehlken et al. 2015 • WHO-FC II–IV
• Receive pulmonary hypertension target drugs, stable condition ≥2 months
Those who do not meet the inclusion criteria
Saglam et al. 2015 • WHO-FC II–III
• Receive pulmonary hypertension target drugs, stable condition ≥3 months
Severe obstructive and restrictive pulmonary diseases, severe ischemic heart disease, left heart failure, pulmonary heart disease, cognitive impairment, infection of virus in nearly 6 months, bone and joint disorder
González-Saiz et al. 2017 • Age >18 years
• Diagnosis of PAH or CTEPH by right cardiac catheterization
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition (>3 months)
• No recent syncope, no musculoskeletal disorder
• WHO-FC II–III
Two people changed targeted drugs before starting exercise training
Fukui et al. 2016 • Inoperable CTEPH who underwent their final BPA with improved resting mean pulmonary arterial pressure of 24.7±5.5 mmHg and who suffered remaining exercise intolerance
• WHO ≥II
One person had skeletal and muscular disorder
Martínez-Quintana et al. 2010 • Age ≥14 years
• No change in drug treatment regimen for pulmonary hypertension in the past 6 months
• WHO-FC II–III
Those who do not meet the inclusion criteria
Fox et al. 2011 • Right heart catheter resting mPAP>25mmHg, PCWP ≤15 mmHg, PVR ≥3 wood Units
• Receive targeted drug therapy, stable treatment for ≥3 months
• NYHA classification II–III
• Level I or IV of NYHA, PAH due to CHD with a right-to-left shunt, left heart disease, chronic hypoxia or chronic lung disease (total lung volume/FEV1 < 60% predicted value)
• Diseases requiring hospitalization occur during case screening
• Any non-PAH medical condition likely to interfere with participation in or completion of the program
• Participants in other rehabilitation programs within 6 months
Grünig/Marier et al. 2012 • PAH related to connective tissue diseases diagnosed by guidelines
• WHO-FC II–IV
• Targeted drugs for pulmonary hypertension and connective tissue disease were administered, and the condition was stable for more than 2 months.
• Severe interstitial lung disease
• One patient was excluded for respiratory infection on follow-up
Grünig/Lichtblau et al. 2012 • WHO-FC II–IV
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥2 months
• New diagnosis of pulmonary hypertension, 2–6 months after receiving new targeted drugs
• Unstable clinical symptoms (6 people)
• Gastrocnemius paralysis occurs after falling (1 person)
• Family problems (2 people)
• MRSA infection (1 person)
• Peripheral arterial occlusion impairing 6MWD (1 person)
Nagel et al. 2012 • Patients with CTEPH during 06/2006 – 10/2011
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥ 2 months
• WHO-FC II–IV
• Change in targeted drugs 2–4 weeks before training (2 people)
• Misdiagnosis (2 people)
Becker-Grünig et al. 2013 • Adult patients with invasively confirmed severe congenital heart disease with PAH during 09/2008 – 10/2011
• Receive targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥2 months
• Newly diagnosed pulmonary hypertension, 2-6 months after receiving new targeted drug therapy
• WHO-FC II–III
Those who do not meet the inclusion criteria
Kabitz et al. 2014 • WHO-FC II–IV
• No recent syncope
• Diagnosis of PAH based on current clinical classification criteria
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥2 months
Complicated with left heart disease, lung disease, rib cage abnormality, neuromuscular abnormality, cachexia, systemic steroid therapy
Grünig et al. 2011 • Severe chronic pulmonary hypertension and right heart failure diagnosed according to guidelines during 01/2003 – 04/2007
• WHO-FC II–IV
• Targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥3 months
• Presence of underlying mitral stenosis as an etiology for PAH (1 person)
• Change in targeted drugs (1 person)
• Family reasons (1 person)
Inagaki et al. 2014 • Outpatients with inoperable or residual CTEPH
• Receive targeted drug therapy, stable condition ≥3 months
• Age 18–80 years old
• WHO-FC II–IV
Individuals with other unstable/severe pulmonary disease or cardiac, orthopedic, or neurological disorders limiting exercise performance
de Man et al. 2009 • Diagnosed with IPAH according to WHO criteria established by RHC
• Stable clinical condition, defined as a change in 6-min walk distance (6MWD) of <10% in three consecutive measurements prior to inclusion (over a period of minimally 1 year), and no change in medical therapy for >3 months
• Aged 18 years. or older
• Living within 5 km of a rehabilitation center associated with the current study
Those who do not meet the inclusion criteria