Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 2;5(4):963–979. doi: 10.1016/j.bioactmat.2020.06.023

Table 5.

Comparison among 3D fabrication technologies.

Gas foaming method Mechanism Gas bubbles generated in situ either via a chemical reaction or solubility difference of CO2 in ethanol and water and depressurization of subcritical CO2 fluid
Advantages Increase the pore size and porosity of scaffold;
Promote cell infiltration migration, proliferation, and angiogenesis
Disadvantages Most scaffolds are restricted of weak mechanical strength; Imprecise thickness control and cause inflammatory; response in vivo;
Hard to be used as a carrier of drugs or factors
Applications Nerve regeneration; Hemostasis; Wound healing; In vitro tissue models
Ref [[31], [32], [33], [34], [35], [36], [37], [38]]
Direct electrospinning Mechanism Collect scaffold directly with a special 3D shaped device; Use a thumbtack as collector producing 3D silica fibrous scaffold via self-assembly; Use the sol-gel solution to produce a bioactive 3D scaffold
Advantages Promote biomineralization and cell infiltration; Reduce bulk density
Disadvantages Uncontrolled shape; Weak mechanical property
Applications Bone regeneration; Oils absorption
Ref [26,[41], [42], [43]]
Short nanofibers assembling into 3D aerogels/scaffolds Mechanism Cut the nanofibrous membrane into small pieces, and then uniformly disperse the small pieces in the medium using a homogenizer. In general, short fibers are introduced into aerogels/scaffolds to enhance their structural stability or serve as an ECM template to provide a suitable microenvironment for cell growth and proliferation.
Advantages Possess various excellent properties such as elastic resilience, energy absorption, shape memory, superabsorbent, and high-pressure sensitivity
Disadvantages Some scaffolds are non-biodegradable, hydrophobic and use toxic cross-linking agents; Complex preparation process
Applications Osteoporotic; Bone regeneration; Cartilage regeneration; Cranial bone regeneration; Thermal insulation; Sound absorption; Emulsion separation
Ref [[44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51]]
3D printing Mechanism Print 3D scaffolds with short fiber ink enabling the scaffold surface with fibrous structures; Use stable jet electrospinning (SJES) to produce aligned ultrafine fibers via strengthening the control of jet instability
Advantages Controlled shape; Promote cell proliferation, infiltration, adhesion and migration
Disadvantages Complex preparation process; Various parameters need to be controlled
Applications Cartilage regeneration; Anisotropic tissue regeneration
Ref [[52], [53], [54], [55]]
Electrospray Mechanism Homogenize electrospun nanofiber mats to generate nanofiber segments and electrospray the crosslinker containing nanofiber segment solution into liquid nitrogen to obtained microspheres.
Advantages Fabricate NMs from any material feasible for electrospinning
Disadvantages Complex preparation process; Crosslinking agent toxicity
Applications Biomimetic and injectable carrier; Osteogenesis; Angiogenesis; Tissue filling; Cell and drug delivery
Ref [56,57]
Origami and cell sheet engineering Mechanism Cells were seeded on both two sides of the electrospun nanofiber film and use the co-cultured membrane to fabricate bio-tubular scaffolds or nanofiber boxes via origami.
Advantages Cell infiltration; Intricate architectures
Disadvantages Complex preparation process; High requirements for operators
Applications 3D tissue construction; Vascular grafts regeneration
Ref [[58], [59], [60]]
Centrifugal electrospinning Mechanism Use an electrospun rotating spinneret and obtain nanofiber from a conductive iron circular collector surrounding the spinneret.
Advantages Promote production rates; High orientation
Disadvantages Require special equipment; Few types of the fiber structure
Applications Mass production of electrospun fibers; Drug release
Ref [61]