Skip to main content
editorial
. 2020 Feb 27;9(5):e04905. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.120.015806

Table 1.

Literature Review of Coronary Physiology Before vs After Treatment of Severe Aortic Stenosis

Author N Baseline Immediate P Value Long‐Term P Value Time Treatment Method
Resting perfusion (mL/min per g) or Doppler velocity (cm/s)
Nemes5 21 62.2 40.1 <0.01 15 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Hildick‐Smith6 27 43 41 NS 6 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Carpeggiani7 8 1.01 0.92 >0.05 12 mo SAVR PET
Rajappan8 22 1.08 1.01 0.27 12 mo SAVR PET
Camugila9 8 22 20 NS 18 NS 12 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Vendrik1 13 19.98 19.7 NS 21.44 0.397 6 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Wiegerinck10 27 24.4 25.5 0.401 TAVI Wire Doppler
Ahmad11 30 22.13 24.84 0.1 TAVI Wire Doppler
Instantaneous wave‐free ratio (iFR)
Vendrik1 13 0.82 0.83 NS 0.83 0.735 6 mo TAVI
Ahmad11 30 0.88 0.88 0.94 TAVI
Scarsini12 145 0.89 0.89 0.66 TAVI
Hyperemic perfusion (mL/min per g) or Doppler velocity (cm/s) or mean transit time (s)
Nemes5 21 117 91.5 <0.05 15 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Hildick‐Smith6 27 71 108 <0.01* 6 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Carpeggiani7 8 1.68 1.46 NS 12 mo SAVR PET
Rajappan8 22 2.17 2.27 0.61 12 mo SAVR PET
Camugila9 8 34 29 NS 39 NS 12 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Vendrik1 13 26.36 30.78 <0.001* 40.2 <0.001* 6 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Wiegerinck10 27 44.5 51.1 0.027* TAVI Wire Doppler
Ahmad11 30 33.44 40.33 0.004* TAVI Wire Doppler
Stoller13 40 0.44 0.48 0.53 TAVI Wire thermo
CFR
Nemes5 21 1.96 2.37 <0.05* 15 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Hildick‐Smith6 27 1.76 2.61 <0.01* 6 mo SAVR Echo Doppler (diastolic)
Carpeggiani7 8 1.68 1.58 NS 12 mo SAVR PET
Rajappan8 22 2.02 2.28 0.17 12 mo SAVR PET
Camugila9 8 1.53 1.58 0.41 2.18 <0.01* 12 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Vendrik1 13 1.28 1.65 <0.001* 1.94 <0.001* 6 mo TAVI Wire Doppler
Wiegerinck10 27 1.9 2.1 0.113 TAVI Wire Doppler
Stoller13 40 1.9 2 0.72 TAVI Wire thermo
FFR
Stundl14 13 0.77 0.76 0.11 2 mo TAVI
Vendrik1 13 0.85 0.79 <0.001* 0.71 <0.001* 6 mo TAVI
Ahmad11 30 0.87 0.85 0.0008* TAVI
Stoller13 40 0.9 0.93 0.0021 TAVI
Pesarini15 133 0.89 0.89 0.73 TAVI

*P values statistically significant and supportive of the hypothesis that treating aortic stenosis does not change resting flow but increases hyperemic flow and associated metrics.

Statistically significant but against this hypothesis.

CFR indicates coronary flow reserve; FFR, fractional flow reserve; iFR, instantaneous wave‐free ratio; NS, not significant (actual P value not reported); PET, positron emission tomography; SAVR, surgical aortic valve replacement; TAVI, transcatheter aortic valve implantation; thermo, bolus thermodilution.