Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Jul 8.
Published in final edited form as: Dev Psychobiol. 2019 Mar 18;61(3):444–464. doi: 10.1002/dev.21831

TABLE 1.

List of salient developmental constructs across the lifespan, paired with theoretically-relevant daily activities and sensing solutions. All mention of annotation refers to coding of data by trained human annotators; all mention of “detection” refers to automated coding via trained machine learning algorithms

Developmental construct Relevant behaviors/exposures Sensing possibilities Sample studies
Temperament & Personality Activity
Daily behavior, routines
Amount of motion from accelerometer
Annotated from wearable camera; EMA
Buss et al. (1980)
Brown et al. (2017)

Child stress and emotional adaptation Child mood & distress

Regulation

Context of child distress
Early: Crying or laughing detected from wearable audio Later: EMA
Early: Duration to soothe detected via wearable audio; Later: EMA
Sporadic annotation (e.g. time locked to tantrums detected from wearable audio)
Rao et al. (2014); Kim and Clements (2015)
Gunthert and Wenze (2011); Silk et al. (2011)
Ludwig (2018); Silk, Steinberg, and Morris (2003)

Caregiving characteristics Tone of interactions
Physical presence and contact

Joint activity

Contingent language
Parental Sensitivity
Detected from wearable audio
Detected from bluetooth or wearable motion sensors
Annotated reading or playing; detected mutual gaze from wearable camera or audio
Detected via LENA wearable audio algorithms
Sporadic annotation (e.g. event-locked to distress detected from wearable audio or within audio “snippets”)
Black et al. (2013); Weusthoff et al. (2013) Olguin et al. (2009); Yao et al. (under review)
Rehg et al. (2013); Soderstrom and Wittebolle (2013)
Zimmerman et al. (2009)
Tobin et al. (2015)

Parental stress Mood
Neurobiological stress reactivity
EMA
Ambulatory cortisol, wearable physiology monitors
Gunthert and Wenze (2011)
Schlotz (2011); Hovsepian et al. (2015)

Household characteristics Chaos of home environment

Household routines

Food availability
Detected via wearable or static audio or camera
Regularity of meal-time detected via water or electrical meter
Wearable camera
Cook etal. (2018)

Froehlich et al. (2009); Gupta et al. (2010)
Jia etal. (2018)

Early perceptual development Visual and auditory experience
Gross motor experience

Fine motor experience
Wearable cameras and audio recorders
Posture and fall detected via wearable motion sensors
Wrist-worn motion sensors; toys with embedded motion sensing
Smith et al. (2015)
Nam and Park (2013)
Varkey, Pompili, and Walls (2012);
Verplaetse (1996); Westeyn et al. (2012)

Language learning Language input and contingency of parental speech Detected via wearable audio (e.g. via LENA algorithms) Zimmerman et al. (2009)

Attention & executive function Daily Cognitive assessments

Time spent distracted in attentional focus
Active assessment collected via mobile phone app
Detected via wearable motion sensors

Cellphone use monitoring application
Maekawa, Anderson, de Brecht, and Yamagishi (2018)
Tawari et al. (2014)

Wang, Chen et al. (2014)

Peer, teacher, or family interactions (incl. e.g. marital or sibling conflict) Quantity of interactions

Classroom activity
 Quality of interactions
Contingent speech detected via wearable audio
Proximity detected via wearable Bluetooth sensors
Detected via static audio recordings
Conflict or supportiveness annotated from snippets via wearable audio recorder
Berke et al. (2011)

Olguin et al. (2009)

Wang, Pan, Miller, and Cortina (2014) Slatcher and Trentacosta (2012); Tobin etal. (2015)

Puberty Hormonal changes Ambulatory assessment of saliva samples Schlotz (2011)

Identity formation Visible advertising or stereotypes Wearable camera with some automated assistance Zhang and Rehg (2018)

Academic success Time spent studying

Afterschool activities
Classroom engagement
Detected via multimodal cellphone sensor monitoring
Geocoded from GPS data
Detected via pressure-sensitive seats, motion and physiological sensors
Wang, Chen et al. (2014)

Byrnes et al. (2017)
Dragon et al. (2008)

Risky activity (sex, drug abuse) Frequency of content words
Alcohol or other substance use

Common activity by location
Transcription of snippets from wearable audio
Detected via multimodal cellphone sensor monitoring; specialized biomarker sensors
Geocoded from GPS data
Pennebaker, Mehl, and Niederhoffer (2003)
Bae et al. (2017);Bertz et al. (2018)

Byrnes et al. (2017)

Aging Cognitive and physical decline Detected via static multimodal platforms Kaye et al.(2011)

Physical & mental health Psychiatric symptoms
Sleep; physical activity; eating episodes
EMA
Detected via motion sensors
aan het Rot, (2012)
Bussmann and Ebner-Priemer(2012); Robillard et al. (2015); Thomaz et al. (2015)

Other relevant exposures Phone use
Nutrition
Sugar consumption
Cell phone monitoring application
Annotated via participant-collected photo logs
Continuous glucose monitoring sensors
Harari et al. (2017)
Cordeiro et al. (2015)

Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (2008)