Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 11;17(12):4363. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17124363

Table 2.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria for retrieval of health legislation and health policies.

Legislations Policies
Criteria Inclusion Exclusion Inclusion Exclusion
Type Enacted legislation detailing financial and institutional arrangements on health service coverage/delivery Laws on human research Action plans, strategies, and policies addressing the following target groups: Action plans focusing only on prevention of noncommunicable diseases
  • -

    People with noncommunicable diseases: cancer, stroke, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

  • -

    Older persons (i.e., aging)

  • -

    Persons with mental health and neurodegenerative disorders (e.g., dementia, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis)

  • -

    People with disabilities and/or chronic conditions

Laws on data protection including regulations regarding the protection of privacy and confidentiality of health information Action plans, strategies, and policies addressing other aspects of health service delivery such as e-health/digital health
Action plans, strategies and policies addressing the following programmatic areas within the health system, including:
Laws and regulations on health professional practice and education
  • -

    Human resources

  • -

    Health financing

  • -

    Service user empowerment

  • -

    Health information systems governance

Environmental health laws Intersectoral action plans on disability (i.e., national strategies for the inclusion/integration of disabled persons)
Food laws Sectoral or multisectoral action plans on rehabilitation
Submitted bills, upcoming bills, law proposals, national constitutions
Timeframe 1980–2018 Pre-1980 Action plans, strategies and policies that are currently under implementation or were implemented within the last three years, i.e., implemented by 2015. Action plans, strategies, and policies completed preceding 2015
Level of implementation National Municipal, Regional Action plans, strategies and policies at the national or federal level Action plans, strategies and policies at regional, municipal, cantonal, and provincial levels
Languages English, German, Swedish, Italian, Dutch All languages not specified in inclusion criteria English, German, Swedish, Italian, Dutch All languages not specified in inclusion criteria
Countries United Kingdom, Italy, Netherlands, Sweden, Germany All countries not specified in inclusion criteria United Kingdom, Italy, Netherlands, Sweden, Germany All countries not specified in inclusion criteria