Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 26;16(6):e1007981. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1007981

Table 1. Results for error correction by POLCA and Pilon on an A. thaliana genome (total size 119Mb) with three different numbers of simulated errors.

Error rates ranged from 0.1% to 0.46%. Boldface indicates the better values for each experiment in each row.

POLCA Pilon
Experiment (error rate) Exp 1 (0.1%) Exp 2 (0.2%) Exp 3
(0.46%)
Exp 1 (0.1%) Exp 2 (0.2%) Exp 3
(0.46%)
Simulated substitution errors 53,726 107,244 267,896 53,726 107,244 267,896
Substitutions fixed (TP) 48,442 97,093 241,883 49,545 98,825 246,405
Substitutions missed (FN) 5,284 10,151 26,013 4,181 8,419 21,491
Substitution errors
introduced (FP)
4 27 68 2,019 3,887 9,471
Simulated indel errors 57,758 112,894 281,332 57,758 112,894 281,332
Indels fixed (TP) 54,802 107,588 268,702 55,463 107,576 261,279
Indels missed (FN) 2,956 5,306 12,630 2,295 5,318 20,053
Indel errors introduced (FP) 237 708 1,560 2,796 5,543 19,177
Total errors remaining after polishing 8,481 16,192 40,271 11,291 23,167 70,192