Table 4.
Global result for 30s frame. The mean (standard deviation) [Maximum Minimum] F1 score obtained for the 30s classifiers in each iteration; (a) corresponds to the subject independent evaluation, (b) corresponds to the subject dependent evaluation, and (c) corresponds to emotion dependent evaluation.
Signal | Condition | Random Forest (Mean % ± std %) | Neural Network (Mean % ± std %) |
---|---|---|---|
All | (a) | 39.07 (1.61) [Max: 43.64%, Min: 37.94%] | 35.82 (1.05) [Max: 38.32%, Min: 34.37%] |
(b) | 30.93 (1.40) [Max: 35.47%, Min: 29.94%] | 31.00 (3.02) [Max: 31.74%, Min: 29.53%] | |
(c) | 76.25 (1.42) [Max: 77.70%, Min: 73.13%] | 50.16 (3.41) [Max: 52.11%, Min: 40.14%] | |
ECG | (a) | 36 (0.78) [Max: 36.73%, Min: 34.25%] | 37 (0.77) [Max: 38.87%, Min: 36.10%] |
(b) | 32.01 (0.83) [Max: 33.21% Min: 30.31%] | 34.63 (1.16) [Max: 35.18% Min: 30.11%] | |
(c) | 49.79 (3.35) [Max: 58.10%, Min: 46.62%] | 37.43 (0.86) [Max: 38.24%, Min: 35.47%] | |
EMGZ | (a) | 34.23 (0.20) [Max: 34.53%, Min: 33.82%] | 33.75 (1.05) [Max: 38.30%, Min: 34.87%] |
(b) | 31.60 (0.96) [Max: 32.74% Min: 30.08%] | 31.12(0.88) [Max: 34.01% Min: 30.97%] | |
(c) | 38.33 (1.66) [Max: 39.80%, Min: 34.95%] | 36.69 (1.40) [Max: 39.70%, Min: 34.69%] | |
EMGMF | (a) | 33.82 (0.29) [Max: 34.33%, Min: 33.32%] | 33 (0.27) [Max: 34.41%, Min: 33.46%] |
(b) | 32.73 (0.43) [Max: 33.37%, Min: 31.68%] | 35.90 (2.88) [Max: 39.97%, Min: 29.48%] | |
(c) | 39.46 (1.16) [Max: 41.65%, Min: 38.17%] | 41.18 (5.23) [Max: 51.98%, Min: 37.05%] | |
EMG | (a) | 35.80 (0.43) [Max: 36.33%, Min: 35.03%] | 36.00 (0.63) [Max: 37.04%, Min: 35.20%] |
(b) | 35.28 (1.08) [Max: 36.73% Min: 33.53%] | 27.67 (1.49) [Max: 29.49% Min: 24.85%] | |
(c) | 49.01 (1.62) [Max: 51.26%, Min: 45.90%] | 36.02 (2.08) [Max: 37.85%, Min: 30.04%] | |
EDA | (a) | 37.53 (1.32) [Max: 38.78%, Min: 34.25%] | 38.98 (0.64) [Max: 39.90%, Min: 37.82%] |
(b) | 36.23 (1.59) [Max: 40.12% Min: 34.93%] | 42.32 (4.46) [Max: 53.90% Min: 39.03%] | |
(c) | 48.79 (2.13) [Max: 51.72%, Min: 43.11%] | 42.77 (3.40) [Max: 46.75%, Min: 33.82%] |