Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 29;14(6):e0008407. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0008407

Table 1. Description of expected biomarker levels found in individuals using an understanding of disease dynamics in a system based on the more traditional (CANONICAL) framework and expanding that framework to include greater complexities and more ambiguous presentations (AMBIGUOUS).

Presentation Antibody Titer Clinical Disease Pathogen Presence Interpretation
CANONICAL
Unexposed/Susceptible (S) Negative Absent No Never exposed
Exposed (E) Negative Absent/Mild Yes Exposed, infected but not yet infectious
Infected/Infectious (I) Positive Severe Yes Recent infection, infectious
Past Exposure/Recovered (R) Positive OR Negative Absent No Recovered
AMBIGUOUS
a High Absent Yes Subclinical infection
OR Delay in clinical manifestation relative to infection and immune response (antibody titer)
OR Recent infection with rapid resolution of clinical disease
b High Absent No Recently cleared infection with resolution of clinical disease.
c Very High Absent No Re-exposure with boosting
d Low to Medium Moderate to Severe No Past (cleared) infection with residual antibodies and persistent clinical compromise despite clearance of pathogen.
OR Past (cleared) infection with residual antibodies and disease from different etiology.
e Absent Moderate to Severe No As in d above, but with no residual antibodies.
f Absent Moderate to Severe Yes Clinical infection, but early stage so no detectable immune response (yet).
g Low to Medium Absent Yes Chronic subclinical infection.
OR Early infection prior to maximum immune response.
OR Individual heterogeneity in maximum immune response.
h Absent Absent Yes As in g above, but with no antibodies detected