Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun;9(3):1394–1404. doi: 10.21037/tau.2020.03.39

Table 2. Meta-analysis results.

Variables N Dominant genetic model (LL+LS vs. SS) Recessive genetic model (LL vs. LS+SS) Homozygous model (LL vs. SS) Heterozygous model (LS vs. SS) Allelic contrast model (L-allele vs. S-allele)
I2 (%) OR (95% CI) P I2 (%) OR (95% CI) P I2 (%) OR (95% CI) P I2 (%) OR (95% CI) P I2 (%) OR (95% CI) P
Overall 8 67.6 0.732 (0.483–1.110) 0.142 75.5 0.827 (0.511–1.339) 0.440 75.9 0.707 (0.391–1.278) 0.251 44.3 0.787 (0.617–1.002) 0.052 65.4 0.830 (0.647–1.066) 0.144
Ethnicities
   Asian 3 72.3 0.977 (0.550–1.733) 0.935 88.3 1.085 (0.397–2.970) 0.873 86.9 1.042 (0.356–3.055) 0.94 7.0 0.920 (0.665–1.273) 0.615 43.5 0.656 (0.539–0.799) <0.001
   Caucasia 4 60.9 0.638 (0.362–1.124) 0.12 0 0.754 (0.536–1.059) 0.103 31.1 0.635 (0.417–0.958) 0.035 61.7 0.669 (0.360–1.243) 0.203 49.3 0.882 (0.715–1.088) 0.240
   Africa 1 0.0 0.240 (0.050–1.140) 0.073 0 0.364 (0.128–1.036) 0.058 0.0 0.168 (0.032–0.884) 0.035 0.0 0.329 (0.063–1.731) 0.189 0.0 0.388 (0.180–0.834) 0.015
Source of control
   HB 3 62.7 0.681 (0.313–1.482) 0.333 34.4 0.734 (0.485–1.109) 0.142 63.4 0.594 (0.237–1.488) 0.266 43.9 0.784 (0.496–1.238) 0.296 76.6 1.071 (0.592–1.939) 0.820
   PB 5 74.7 0.748 (0.432–1.296) 0.301 82.6 0.924 (0.463–1.846) 0.823 81.9 0.776 (0.345–1.750) 0.542 55.6 0.738 (0.471–1.155) 0.183 56.2 0.746 (0.576–0.967) 0.027
SPE vs. Con 2 0.0 0.852 (0.484–1.500) 0.578 0.0 0.793 (0.447–1.405) 0.426 0.0 0.772 (0.388–1.538) 0.462 0.0 0.924 (0.493–1.732) 0.805 0.0 0.853 (0.594–1.224) 0.384

N, number; OR, odds ratio; CI, confidence interval; PH, pheterogeneity; HB, hospital based; PB, population based.