Table 2.
Study | Type | Population | Intervention and comparator | Outcomes | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
PEARL I | Randomised Double blind Placebo controlled |
Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–50 years; BMI: 18–40 kg/m2; PBAC score >100 (first 8 days of menstruation); At least one uterine fibroid >3 cm but <10 cm; Fibroid uterus: <6 weeks; Anaemia: Hb <10.2 g/dL; Eligible for surgery |
Women were randomised in a ratio of 2:2:1 to 5 mg/day UPA (n = 96) 10 mg/day UPA (n = 98) Placebo (n = 48) Treatment duration 12–13 weeks All women received 80 mg/day oral iron |
PBAC score <75 was achieved in 5 mg UPA group (91%) 10 mg UPA group (92%) Placebo (19%) Amenorrhoea (PBAC <2) in 10 days 5 mg UPA group (73%) 10 mg UPA group (82%) Placebo (6%) Median total change in fibroid volume 5 mg UPA group (−21.2%) 10 mg UPA group (−12.3%) Placebo (+3%) Self-reported pain scores improved compared to placebo Adverse effects comparable to placebo |
Treatment with ulipristal acetate for 13 weeks effectively controlled excessive bleeding due to uterine fibroids and reduced the size of the fibroids. |
PEARL II | Randomised Double Blind Double Dummy Active Comparator Controlled Noninferiority |
Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–50 years BMI: 18–40 kg/m2; PBAC score >100 (first 8 days of menstruation); At least one uterine fibroid >3 cm but <10 cm; Fibroid uterus <16 weeks; Eligible for surgery |
Women were randomised in a ratio of 1:1:1 to 5 mg/day UPA + placebo* (n = 97), 10 mg/day UPA + placebo (n = 104), placebo + Leuprorelin 3.75 mg IM monthly (n = 101) Treatment duration: 12–13 weeks *Placebo in UPA group - IM saline injection |
PBAC score <75 was achieved in 5 mg UPA group (90%) 10 mg UPA group (98%) Leuprorelin (89%); Amenorrhoea (PBAC <2) was achieved 5 mg UPA group (75%) - Median time 7 days 10 mg UPA group (89%) - Median time 5 days Leuprorelin (80%) - Median time 21 days Median total change in fibroid volume 5 mg UPA group (−36%) 10 mg UPA group (−42%) Leuprorelin (−53%) Hot flushes (moderate to severe) 5 mg UPA group (11%) 10 mg UPA group (10%) Leuprorelin (40%) All three groups had improvements in pain and QoL scores |
Treatment with ulipristal acetate for 13 weeks was noninferior to leuprolide acetate in controlling uterine bleeding and was associated with significantly lower risk of hot flushes. |
PEARL III + Extension 1 | PEARL III- Open label Extension 1 - Randomised double blind |
Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–48 years; BMI: 18–40 kg/m2; Regular menstrual cycle; PBAC score >100 (first 8 days of menstruation); At least one uterine fibroid >3 cm but <10 cm; (FSH) <20 IU/L; Fibroid uterus <16 weeks; Eligible for surgery |
PEARL III - UPA 10mg/day commenced in the first week of menstruation. Treatment duration 12 weeks (n = 209); Extension 1 - Up to 4 courses of 12 weeks of UPA treatment with drug free intervals, followed by randomised double blind treatment (1:1) to norethisterone acetate (NETA) or placebo for 10 days at the end of each treatment course. (n = 132)* *Participants recruited from the core PEARL III study |
Amenorrhoea (PBAC <2) was achieved 1st UPA course (79.5%) - Median time 3.5 days 2nd UPA course (88.5%) - Median time 2 days 3rd UPA course (88.2%) - Median time 3 days 4th UPA course (89.7%) - Median time 3 days Median total change in fibroid volume 1st UPA course (−45.1%), n = 132 2nd UPA course (−63.2%), n = 131 3rd UPA course (−67%), n = 119 4th UPA course (−72.1%), n = 107 Hot flushes (moderate to severe) PAEC (6 weeks post treatment) 26% after course 1 25% after course 4 No effect of NETA on PAEC Improvement in pain scores appeared by the fifth week and was maintained during the four cycles. Quality-of-life scores were considerably reduced at the end of the treatment compared with scores at baseline and maintained throughout and at 3 months after cessation of treatment. |
The study and its extensions (see subsequent section) demonstrates the safety and efficacy of repeated intermittent treatment of symptomatic fibroids with UPA. |
PEARL III + Extension 2 | PEARL III- Open label | Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–48 years; BMI: 18–40 kg/m2; Regular menstrual cycle; PBAC score >100 (first 8 days of menstruation); At least one uterine fibroid >3 cm but <10 cm; Fibroid uterus <16 weeks; Eligible for surgery; Completed PEARL III core study and extension 1 |
Extension 2 - Up to four additional courses of 12 weeks of UPA treatment with drug free intervals - TOTAL up to 8 courses (n = 64) * *Participants recruited from the core PEARL III study + completed extension 1 |
PAEC (assessed post treatment) 21% after course 4 16% after course 8 No changes in laboratory results outside normal ranges at any time |
The study and its extensions demonstrate the safety and efficacy of repeated intermittent treatment of symptomatic fibroids with UPA. |
PEARL IV | Randomised Double Blind Parallel-Group |
Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–50 years; BMI: 18–40 kg/m2; Regular menstrual cycle; PBAC score >100 (first 8 days of menstruation); At least one uterine fibroid ≥3 cm but ≤12 cm; FSH <20 IU/L; Fibroid uterus <16 weeks |
Women were randomised in a ratio of 1:1 to 5 mg/day UPA (n = 230) 10 mg/day UPA (n = 221) Treatment duration - Up to four courses of 12 weeks each (84 days) with a drug free interval between courses; until the start of the second menstrual bleed after course completion Women were followed up at 3 months after the fourth treatment course |
Amenorrhoea (PBAC <2) was achieved 5 mg UPA group Course 1 - 71.8% Course 2 - 74.1% Course 3 - 73.3% Course 4 - 69.6% All four courses combined - 48.7% 10 mg UPA group Course 1- 82.6% Course 2 - 82.2% Course 3 - 78.3% Course 4 - 74.5% All 4 courses combined - 60.5% Median change in volume of the 3 largest fibroids at follow up 5 mg UPA group (−65%) 10 mg UPA group (−67.4%) Placebo (−53%) PAEC 5 mg UPA group Baseline - 7.8% Course 2 (16.3%) & Course 4 (16.2%) 3 months post UPA - 9.0% 10 mg UPA group Baseline - 8.4% Course 2 (19.2%) & Course 4 (10.3%) 3 months post UPA - 6.3% Both groups had improvements in pain and QoL scores Headaches and hot flushes were the most commonly reported side effects and occurred in ≤11% of patients, with the frequency of these events decreasing with each successive treatment course. |
The study demonstrates the safety and efficacy of repeated intermittent treatment of symptomatic fibroids with UPA. |
VENUS II | Randomised Double Blind Placebo Controlled Partial Crossover |
Women with symptomatic fibroids; Age: 18–50 years; Regular menstrual cycle; MBL ≥80 mL measured using the alkali hematin method (first 8 days of menstruation) Minimum one discrete leiomyoma seen by TVUS FS) <20 IU/L Fibroid uterus ≤20 weeks |
Women were randomised (n = 432) 5 mg/day UPA 10 mg/day UPA Placebo Randomized to one of six treatment arms in a 1:1:2:1:2:1 ratio, with course 1, course 2 dosing of placebo, ulipristal 5 mg; placebo, ulipristal 10 mg; ulipristal 5 mg, 5 mg; ulipristal 5 mg, placebo; ulipristal 10 mg, 10 mg; ulipristal 10 mg, placebo Treatment duration - Two courses of 3 months each. There was a two menses drug-free interval in between courses. Women were followed up at 3 months after treatment completion |
Amenorrhoea was achieved 5 mg UPA group Course 1 - 42% Course 2 - 40.5% 10 mg UPA group Course 1- 54.8% Course 2 - 57.3% Placebo Course 1- 0% Course 2 - 8% Improvement from baseline in UFS-QOL revised activities subscale: 5-mg UPA: 48% 10-mg UPA: 57% Placebo: 13% |
Consistent with VENUS I and the European studies, both doses of UPA were superior to placebo in the proportion of women achieving amenorrhea and time to amenorrhea. |