Table 2.
NIR | IR | Raman | |
---|---|---|---|
Spectral region
wavelength [nm] wavenumbers [cm−1] |
1000–2500 10,000–4000 |
2500–25,000 4000–400 |
2500–200,000 4000–50 |
excitation mechanism | absorption | absorption | inelastic photon scattering |
relative complexity of instrumentation | low | medium | high |
selection rule (chemical sensitivity) | change in dipole moment (polar moieties, enhanced signal of X–H groups, e.g., O–H, N–H, C–H) | change in dipole moment (polar moieties) | change in polarizability (non-polar symmetrical bonds, e.g., C–C, skeletal vibrations) |
sampling (i.e., spectra acquisition modes) | transmission; diffuse reflection; transflection | transmission; diffuse reflection (only after sample preparation); transflection; attenuated total reflectance (ATR) | reflection (scattering) |
remarks about sample preparation | no/minimal sample preparation needed; moderate suitability of water as solvent or glass as container/optics |
optimal sample thickness (in transmission mode); sample dilution (e.g., KBr pellet) for diffuse reflectance mode; optimal/stable sample-IRE contact surface (in ATR mode) |
suitability of water as solvent or glass as container/optics |
chemical specificity | low to moderate | high | high |
major issues and challenges | low sensitivity; overlapping contributions in the spectra; difficult spectral interpretation; |
limited suitability of moist samples; unsuitability of glass optics and materials (absorption of glass); interfering signal from atmospheric H2O and CO2 |
Raman signal obscured by autofluorescence (stronger for excitation lasers with shorter emission wavelengths); laser heating, danger of destruction of molecular structure, e.g., proteins; or sample thermal decomposition (particularly of dried material) |
Abbreviations: IRE - internal reflection element.