Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 27;112(7):671–687. doi: 10.1093/jnci/djaa048

Table 2.

Health insurance coverage disruptions and cancer screeninga

Reference Sample size, No. Setting, data source, and year Insurance coverage measures Outcome measures Key findings
Ayanian et al., 2000 (27) 223 128 adults aged 18-64 y National; BRFSS, 1997-1998 Self-reported short-term uninsured (uninsured <1 y) with coverage gap <1 year vs currently insured (private and/or public) Self-reported Pap test ≤3 y, mammography ≤2 y, fecal occult blood test ≤2 y, and sigmoidoscopy ≤5 y among eligible adults
  • 4.3 % short-term uninsured

  • Compared with currently insured, short-term uninsured were less likely to receive mammography (78.7% vs 89.0%, P < .05) or Pap test (89.5% vs 93.7%, P < .05)

  • No differences observed for receipt of CRC screenings

Bednarek and Schone, 2003 (28) 11 755 women aged 21-64 y National; MEPS, 1996 Self-reported duration of private or public coverage, measured as 1-6 mo, 7-11 mo vs all 12 mo Self-reported use of mammography and Pap test ≤2 y among eligible women
  • Percentage short-term insured 1-6 and 7-11 mo not reported

  • Compared with continuously insured for 12 mo, insured for 1-6 mo less likely to have Pap smears (79.9% vs 70.7%, P < .05) or mammograms (66.7% vs 53.6%, P < .05)

  • Compared with insured 7-12 mo, insured 1-6 mo were less likely to have Pap smears (81.8% vs 70.7%, P < .05) or mammograms (67.0% vs 53.6%, P < .05). Continuously insured and insured 7-12 mo did not statistically significant differ

Broyles et al., 2002 (29) 1512 women aged ≥18 y Oklahoma’s BRFSS, 1993 Self-reported temporarily uninsured with coverage gap previous year vs continuously insured Self-reported use of mammography (in the past 2 y) and Pap test screening (in the past 3 y) among eligible women
  • Percentage temporarily uninsured in previous year not reported

  • Use of mammograms and Pap smears similar in temporarily uninsured and continuously insured (OR = 0.8 and OR = 0.9, respectively; both P > .05)

Freund et al., 2019 (30) 333 adults aged 40-74 y Minority race/ethnicity or low SES participants recruited across 4 sites in 3 states: Chinese Americans in Boston, MA; Hispanic in Columbus, OH; Appalachian populations in OH’s Appalachian region; and African American and Black populations in Philadelphia, PA. Patients recruited from community-based organizations, faith-based organizations, public housing, screening events, health fairs, and from existing research studies. Years of data collection not stated Self-reported insurance instability in past 12 mo defined as uninsured, losing coverage, or changing insurance vs stable insurance status (insured, uninsured) Self-reported use of screening and date of last test. Up to date for BC, cervical cancer, or CRC screening status calculated per USPSTF
  • 32.8% reported insurance instability

  • No statistically significant differences in BC (72.6% vs 80.6%, P = .23), cervical cancer (67.2% vs 73.4%, P = .48), and CRC (61.4% vs 70.1%, P = .19) screening between adults with insurance coverage instability compared with those with stable coverage

Jerant et al., 2013 (31) 92 809 adults aged ≥18 y National; MEPS, 2000-2008; 2-y panels Self-reported insurance loss during 2-y follow-up period vs no private and/or public coverage change (continuously insured and continuously uninsured) Self-reported use of CRC screening (fecal occult blood testing ≤2 y and/or endoscopy ≤5 y), Pap test ≤3 y, and mammography ≤2 y among eligible adults 3193 adults lost insurance. Those with insurance loss less likely to receive Pap (OR = 0.6, 95% CI = 0.5 to 0.8) and mammography (OR = 0.6, 95% CI = 0.4 to 0.8) than those without insurance change. Also less likely to receive CRC screenings, but association not statistically significant (OR = 0.7, 95% CI = 0.4 to 1.0)
Koroukian, 2004 (32) 140 592 women aged 40-64 y Ohio Medicaid claims and enrollment files, 1992-1999 Duration of coverage = length of enrollment in Medicaid (≤12, 13-24, 25-36 mo, etc [up to 8 y]) Receipt of annual and regular annual screening mammography from claims
  • 40.7% enrolled ≤12 mo, 17.6% enrolled 13-24 mo, 41.7% enrolled >24 mo

  • Proportion of women receiving screening mammography increased statistically significantly each additional year of Medicaid enrollment (AOR = 1.6, 95% CI = 1.6 to 1.6)

  • Mean annual mammograms increased from 0.08 in women with enrollment ≤12 mo to 0.26 in women with enrollment ≥7 y

McWilliams et al., 2003 (37) 2036 adults aged 60-64 y in 1996; No. of women not stated National; Health and Retirement Study, 1994, 1996 Self-reported coverage gap measured as intermittently insured (insured in either 1994 or 1996) vs privately and/or publicly insured in both 1994 and 1996 (continuously insured) Self-reported mammography ≤2 y
  • 216 were intermittently insured

  • Compared with continuously insured, intermittently insured less likely to receive mammography (76.0% vs 57.7%, P < .05)

O’Leary et al., 2019 (38) 10 831 adults who turned 50 y during 2010-2013 Oregon Medicaid claims data, 2010-2014 New enrollment in Medicaid at 50 y vs prior enrollment before 50 y CRC screening with colonoscopy, sigmoidoscopy, or stool testing from claims within 12 mo of age 50 y
  • Percentage newly enrolled not reported

  • No differences in CRC screening newly enrolled in Medicaid and prior enrollment (RR = 1.0, 95% CI = 0.8 to 1.3, P = .87)

Staras et al., 2010 (39) 237 015 girls aged 9-17 y Florida Medicaid enrollment and claims, June 2006 to Dec 2008 Coverage duration measured as no. of months enrolled in Medicaid (1–31) At least 1 HPV vaccine claim
  • Percentages by duration of months enrolled in Medicaid not reported

  • Longer length of Medicaid enrollment positively associated with receipt of at least 1 HPV vaccination. HPV vaccination rates were 3.5%, 12.8%, 19.0%, 22.2%, 28.4% for girls enrolled in Medicaid for 1-7, 8-13, 14-19, 20-25, 26-31 mo, respectively

a

AOR = adjusted odds ratio; BC = breast cancer; BRFSS = Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance Survey; CI = confidence interval; CRC = colorectal cancer; MEPS = Medical Expenditure Panel Survey; OR = odds ratio; RR = risk ratio; SES = socioeconomic status; USPSTF = United States Preventive Services Task Force.