Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 13;8(9):e1132–e1141. doi: 10.1016/S2214-109X(20)30288-6

Table 2.

Assumptions of how HIV, tuberculosis, and malaria programmes will be affected by COVID-19 in different response scenarios

Limitations on activities
Demand on health system
During period of recovery
Mitigation or well managed suppression Unmanaged suppression* High demand Extremely high demand
HIV Care seeking reduced: rate of new ART initiations reduced by 25%, 2% of individuals on ART become virally unsuppressed per month; prevention services partially suspended: no new VMMC, no new PrEP enrolments; reduced social contact: 10% reduction in chance of acquiring new sexual partner Care seeking reduced: rate of new ART initiations reduced by 50%, 1% of individuals on ART stop per month due to inability to attend appointments; prevention services suspended: no renewals of PrEP prescriptions Care, medicine, and diagnosis less available at facilities: no new ART initiations, 25% of individuals on ART pre-pandemic have their ART use interrupted, an additional 10% of individuals on ART become virally unsuppressed due to lack of viral load testing; prevention services suspended: no new VMMC or PrEP enrolments; no renewals of PrEP prescriptions Supply of drugs and commodities interrupted: 50% of individuals on ART pre-pandemic have their ART use interrupted, condom use reduced by 50% All services and behaviours resume to pre-pandemic levels immediately
Tuberculosis Care seeking reduced: diagnosis rates decrease by 25% compared with pre-pandemic levels, patient delays before the first presentation to care increased by 25% compared with pre-pandemic levels; displacement of diagnostic resources: diagnosis rate for tuberculosis and drug-resistant tuberculosis decreased by a further 45% due to non-availability of Xpert MTB/Rif diagnostics, yielding overall reduction of 70%; reduced social contact: transmission reduced by 10% Care seeking reduced: tuberculosis and drug-resistant tuberculosis diagnosis rates decrease by 50%, patient delays before first presentation to care increased by 50% compared with pre-pandemic levels; displacement of diagnostic resources: diagnosis rate for tuberculosis and drug-resistant tuberculosis decreased by a further 20% due to non-availability of Xpert MTB/Rif diagnostics, yielding overall reduction of 70%; prevention services suspended: no new IPT for people with HIV Care, medicine, and diagnosis less available at facilities: treatment completion rates decrease by 25% for first-line and second-line treatment compared with pre-pandemic levels, patient delays before first presentation to care increased by 50% compared with pre-pandemic levels, drug-resistant tuberculosis diagnosis rates decrease by 50% compared with pre-pandemic levels; prevention services suspended: no new IPT for people with HIV Supply of drugs interrupted: treatment initiation rates decrease to 50% of pre-pandemic levels; drug-resistant tuberculosis diagnosis rates decrease to 0% (also impacted by diagnosis not being available) All services and behaviours resume to pre-pandemic levels immediately
Malaria Care seeking reduced: treatment of clinical cases reduced by 25% compared with pre-pandemic levels; prevention services partially suspended: LLIN mass distribution continues as normal, SMC at 50% of normal coverage Care seeking reduced: treatment of clinical cases reduced by 50% compared with pre-pandemic levels; prevention services suspended: LLIN mass campaigns halted, SMC halted Care, medicine, and diagnosis less available at facilities: treatment of clinical cases reduced by 25% compared with pre-pandemic levels; prevention services suspended: LLIN mass campaigns halted, SMC halted Supply of drugs interrupted: treatment of clinical cases reduced by 50% compared with pre-pandemic levels Treatment of clinical cases remains at reduced level for 2 months; all other services and behaviours resume to pre-pandemic levels immediately

ART=antiretroviral therapy. VMMC=voluntary medical male circumcision. PrEP=pre-exposure prophylaxis. IPT=isoniazid preventive therapy. LLIN=long-lasting insecticide-treated nets. SMC=seasonal malaria chemoprevention.

*

These changes are assumed to be in addition to those that occur during the mitigation interventions.

These changes are assumed to be in addition to those that occur during the period of high demand.