Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 7;11:606. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2020.00606

Table 3.

Meta-analysed effects on peak oxygen uptake (VO2peak), body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference expressed as population mean effects in control and exercise groups, and as modifying effects of exercise duration, baseline, and dietary co-intervention.

VO2peakb BMIc Waist circumferenced
Mean (%) 90% CL (%) Magnitude Mean (%) 90% CL (%) Magnitude Mean (%) 90% CL (%) Magnitude
Population mean effectsa
Control group 1.0 −2.3, 4.4 Trivialooo 0.7 −0.2, 1.7 Trivial0000 0.8 −1.2, 2.8 Trivial00
Moderate exercise 18.4 11.2, 26.1 Moderate↑**** −0.9 −2.0, 0.3 Trivial0000 −1.6 −3.7, 0.5 Trivial00
Vigorous exercise 24.2 18.5, 30.1 Moderate↑**** −2.6 −3.6, −1.7 Trivial000 −3.4 −5.3, −1.5 Small↓**
Moderate—control group 17.2 9.7, 25.3 Moderate↑*** −1.6 −2.9, −0.2 Trivial0000 −2.4 −4.1, −0.6 Small↓*
Vigorous—control group 22.9 16.9, 29.2 Moderate↑**** −3.3 −4.5, −2.2 Trivial00 −4.2 −6.0, −2.3 Small↓**
Modifying effects
Baseline in control group 4.9 −1.4, 11.6 Trivial0 1.3 −1.2, 3.9 Trivial000 0.8 −2.9, 4.7 Trivial
Baseline in exercise group −10.3 −17.6, −2.4 Small↓** 0.8 −1.3, 3.0 Trivial000 −2.2 −5.9, 1.8 Small*
30 h of exercise duration −0.8 −7.8, 6.8 Trivial −1.3 −2.8, 0.2 Trivial0000 −3.6 −6.0, −1.2 Small↓**
Diet in control group −1.9 −11.1, 8.2 Trivial −5.6 −8.4, −2.7 Small↓** −7.5 −10.7, −4.3 Moderate↓***
Diet in exercise group −1.4 −10.0, 8.0 Trivial −2.9 −4.6, −1.2 Trivial00 −1.0 −4.3, 2.5 Trivial00
a

Evaluated at mean baseline (VO2peak = 24 mL.kg.min-1, BMI = 31 kg.m2, waist circumference = 97 cm), training time = 30 h, and no dietary co-intervention.

b

Modifying effect of baseline is evaluated per 70% difference in baseline value.

c

Modifying effect of baseline is evaluated per 40% difference in baseline value.

d

Modifying effect of baseline is evaluated per 25% difference in baseline value.

90% CL 90% compatibility limits, ↑ increase, ↓ decrease.

Effects are shown with their observed magnitudes, determined by standardisation. Clear effects are show with the probability of either a true substantial change (*possibly, **likely, ***very likely, ****most likely) and/or a true trivial change (0possibly, 00likely, 000very likely, 0000most likely). Magnitudes in bold are clear with 99% compatibility intervals.