Table 1.
Factor | Cofactors | Type of Protein | Mode of instability |
Reported effects | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
pH | mAbs | conformational | Low pH (2.7) increases IgG hydrophobicity and induces aggregation. | [29] | |
pH | mAbs | conformational | pH-shift from 2 to 7 induces irreversible aggregates. | [30] | |
pH | mAbs | conformational | IgG subclasses respond differently to pH-induced aggregation. | [31] | |
pH | mAbs | conformational | Nivolumab is susceptible to aggregation (30%) at pH 3.5. IgG4 aggregation is dependent on the Fc region. Propensity to acid-induced aggregation: IgG4 > IgG2 > aglyco-IgG1 > IgG1. |
[32] | |
pH | Temp | Fc fusion protein | conformational | Reducing pH 7, 30°C to pH 6.7, 27°C significantly decreases aggregation. | [33] |
Temp | pH | Fc fusion protein mAb |
conformational | Low temperature and/or low pH in a mammalian cell culture reduce misfolded and aggregated proteins. | [34] |
pH | Excipient | mAbs | colloidal | Isoelectric precipitation of plasma proteins leads to dextrose-mediated mAbs aggregation. | [35] |
Freeze-thaw | pH | mAbs Fc fusion protein |
conformational | Adjusting protein solution (frozen at pH 3) in a higher pH buffer (pH 7) during thawing increases aggregation. | [36] |
Freeze-thaw | mAbs | conformational | Slow thawing induces highest aggregate and subvisible particle levels. Fast freeze and fast thaw are better for mAbs. |
[37] | |
Chemical modification | pH | mAbs | colloidal | Deamination increases aggregation at low pH 3.8. | [38] |
Chemical modification | pH/Temp | mAbs Fc fusion proteins |
conformational colloidal | Met oxidation induces aggregation at low pH and high temperature. Trp oxidation and Asn deamidation induces covalent crosslinked and attractive colloidal interactions. |
[39] |
Chemical modification | Biotherapeutic protein | conformational | Asn deamidation causes less unfolding at the aggregation hotspots identified with NMR compared to methionine oxidation. | [40] | |
Buffer | Ion | bispecific Ab | colloidal | His + Glu at low ionic strength stabilize antibody and reduce aggregation. | [41] |
Ion | pH | mAbs | colloidal | Accumulation of citrate ions at the protein surface decreases protein-protein repulsion (compared to acetate buffer). | [42] |
Ion | mAbs | conformational colloidal | Sodium citrate buffer reduces protein stability compared to sodium acetate buffer. | [43] |