Table 2.
Procedure for evaluation of the apps.
Reference | Area of assessment | Object of the assessment | Basis of the assessment criteria (includes legal framework) |
Papageorgiou et al, 2018 [6] | Privacy and security | In-app information Static and dynamic analyses App communications Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Authors Legal |
Minen et al, 2018 [14] | Privacy | Static and dynamic analyses App communications Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Authors |
Huckvale et al, 2019 [15] | Privacy | In-app information App communications Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Literature |
Scott et al, 2015 [19] | Privacy and security | App properties and behavior Existence of a privacy policy |
Literature |
Brüggemann et al, 2016 [20] | Privacy | App properties and behavior Personal information types App communications |
Authors Literature |
Mense et al, 2016 [21] | Privacy | App communications | Author |
Hutton et al, 2018 [22] | Privacy | App properties and behavior In-app information Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Literature Legal Recommendations or principles |
Zapata et al, 2014 [23] | Privacy | App properties and behavior Existence of a privacy policy |
Literature Legal |
Sunyaev et al, 2015 [24] | Privacy | Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy Legibility of the privacy policy |
Authors |
Leigh et al, 2017 [25] | Multidimensional | In-app information Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Legal Recommendations or principles |
Baumel et al, 2017 [26] | Multidimensional | Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Literature |
Bachiri et al, 2018 [27] | Privacy | App properties and behavior Existence of a privacy policy |
Literature Legal Recommendations or principles |
de las Aguas Robustillo Cortés et al, 2014 [28] | Multidimensional | App properties and behavior In-app information |
Recommendations or principles |
Quevedo-Rodríguez and Wagner, 2019 [29] | Multidimensional | App properties and behavior In-app information Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Recommendations or principles |
Knorr et al, 2015 [30] | Privacy and security | Legibility of the privacy policy | Recommendations or principles |
Zapata et al, 2014 [31] | Privacy | App properties and behavior Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Authors Recommendations or principles |
Bondaronek et al, 2018 [32] | Privacy and security | Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Recommendations or principles |
O’Laughlin et al, 2019 [33] | Privacy | Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Authors |
Adhikari et al, 2014 [34] | Privacy and security | App properties and behavior In-app information Existence of a privacy policy |
Literature |
Aliasgari et al, 2018 [35] | Privacy and security | App communications | Legal |
Mense et al, 2016 [36] | Privacy and security | App communications | Authors Recommendations or principles |
Powell el al, 2018 [37] | Privacy | Existence of a privacy policy Legibility of the privacy policy |
Authors |
Huckvale et al, 2015 [38] | Privacy and security | App properties and behavior In-app information Static and dynamic analyses App communications Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy |
Legal |
Robillard et al, 2019 [39] | Privacy | Existence of a privacy policy Content of the privacy policy Legibility of the privacy policy |
Authors Literature |