Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 20;10(7):e037473. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-037473

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Study Study design Aim Country Income level Start of data collection End of data collection ALF case definition
Alam et al, 200916 Prospective cohort To evaluate the aetiology, complications and outcome of FHF Bangladesh Lower middle 3 Nov 8 May Occurrence of hepatic encephalopathy within 8 weeks of onset of jaundice in patients with no previous liver disease and the presence of coagulopathy as proved by a PT>15 s or INR>1.5
Asim et al, 200917 Cross sectional To analyse serum samples from patients with ALF for hepatitis A-G viral markers India Lower middle 1 Jun 4 May Patient become deeply jaundiced and went into hepatic encephalopathy within 8 weeks of onset of the disease, with no history of chronic hepatitis
Bechmann et al, 201418 Retrospective cohort To identify currently predominant aetiologies of ALF at a transplant centre Germany High 1 Jan 12 Feb Acute Liver Failure Study Group Germany case definition: INR>1.5 and encephalopathy of any grade. Pre-existing liver disease and systemic cause of liver failure were excluded
Bhatia et al, 201319 Prospective cohort To analyse clinical features, liver function tests, hepatitis viral markers and clinical outcomes in patients with ALF India Lower middle Jun 99 1 Jan Development of hepatic encephalopathy within 26 weeks of the first symptoms of acute hepatitis-like illness without any history of underlying liver disease
Borkakoti et al, 201320 Prospective cohort To determine the viral load of HEV and its association with the disease severity in patients with ALF in comparison with patients with ALF due to other hepatides India Lower middle 6 Jan 11 Dec Development of encephalopathy within 8 weeks of the onset of jaundice without any history of chronic liver disease; diagnosed as a self-limiting disease and a serum aspartate aminotransferase elevation of at least fivefold or clinical jaundice or both
Bravo et al, 201221 Prospective and retrospective cohort To investigate the aetiology, outcomes and incidence of AHF among children 0–18 years old Philippines Lower middle Jan 00 6 Dec Onset of coagulopathy and/or encephalopathy ≤4 weeks after the onset of symptoms, a prothrombin time >2, an increased bilirubin and evidence for liver failure complicated by encephalopathy
Cervio et al, 20113 Retrospective cohort To investigate the impact of HAV UI on the trends in the occurrence of FHF in children Argentina High Mar 93 5 Jul Mieli-Vergani case definition: a multisystem disorder in which severe impairment of liver function, with or without encephalopathy, occurs in association with hepatocellular necrosis in a patient with or without recognised underlying chronic liver disease22
Das et al, 201623 Prospective cohort To determine the profile of ALF etiologies India Lower middle 7 Jan 15 Dec History of development of encephalopathy within 8 weeks of disease onset
Gupta et al, 201524 Retrospective cohort To determine the profile of hepatitis A, B, C and E as a cause of AHF in children in a tertiary care hospital India Lower middle 11 Jan 14 Dec Elevated ALT levels or AST of at least fivefold with clinical jaundice and without evidence of chronic liver disease. Patients who had INR>1.5 with encephalopathy or INR>2 without encephalopathy
Ho et al, 201425 Prospective cohort To investigate the incidence, aetiology, outcomes and prognostic factors of ALF Taiwan High income 05 Jan 07 Sep International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) code 570.0
Latif et al, 201026 Prospective cohort To identify the risk factors for FHF and their relationship with the outcome in children Pakistan Lower middle 6 Sep 7 Feb Development of encephalopathy within 8 weeks of the onset of jaundice having evidence of coagulopathy, that is, PT deranges >4 s of control and deranged liver function that is, TSB>1.5 mg/dL, AT>40 IU/L
Mamun et al, 200927 Retrospective cohort To assess the burden of HEV as a cause of ALF Bangladesh Lower middle 4 Jun 6 Dec Previously healthy patients who presented with severe impairment of hepatocellular function, that is, encephalopathy, coagulopathy and jaundice, within 6 months of onset of symptoms
Manka et al, 201528 Retrospective cohort To investigate the causes of previously diagnosed indeterminate cases ALF Germany High 6 Nov 13 Dec Significant liver dysfunction with pathologically increased laboratory parameters (AST, ALT, AP), an existing coagulopathy in terms of an INR>1.5, and with the concomitant presence of any degree of encephalopathy
Mendizabal et al, 201429 Retrospective cohort To determine the causes and short-term outcomes of ALF Argentina High 5 Jun 11 Dec Presence of coagulopathy (INR> 1.5 or prothrombin index <50%)and any grade of HE within 26 weeks of the first symptoms without a known underlying liver disease
Mishra et al, 201630 Retrospective cohort To assess the relative efficacy of HEV antigen detection by ELISA in patients with ALF India Lower middle 13 Nov 15 Jan Any evidence of coagulation abnormality, generally INR>1.5 and any degree of mental alteration (encephalopathy) without pre-existing cirrhosis and with an illness of <4 weeks duration
Mumtaz et al, 200931 Prospective cohort compared with historical control To assess the aetiology, prothrombin time (PT), alanine aminotransferase, creatinine, albumin for non-acetaminophen-induced ALF Pakistan Lower middle Jan 00 7 Mar Rapid development of acute liver injury with impaired synthetic function and encephalopathy in a person who previously had a normal liver
Pandit et al, 201532 Retrospective cohort To assess the frequency of hepatotropic viruses as aetiological agents of ALF India Lower middle 3 Jan 5 Dec Onset of encephalopathy ≤28 days after the onset of symptoms with INR>2 and increased bilirubin complicated by encephalopathy in patients without a previous history of liver disease
Poovorawan et al, 201333 Prospective cohort To determine the causes and outcomes of Thai children with AHF Thailand Upper middle 2 Jan 5 Sep International Association for the Study of the Liver case definition: (Tandon et al, 1999)9
Schwarz et al, 201434 Retrospective cohort—Patient registry To analyse results of viral testing among non-acetaminophen ALF study participants USA/Canada/UK High Dec 99 12 Dec No known evidence of chronic liver disease, with evidence of acute liver injury, and hepatic-based coagulopathy not corrected by vitamin K with the follow parameters: PT≥15 s or INR≥1.5 in the presence of clinical HE or a PT≥20 s or INR≥2.0 regardless of the presence or absence of clinical HE
Shalimar et al, 201735 Retrospective cohort To assess the differences in the course of HEV-ALF as compared with other aetiologies of ALF India Lower middle Jan 86 15 Dec International Association for the Study of Liver (IASL) case definition: Occurrence of encephalopathy within 4 weeks from the onset of symptoms in the absence of pre-existing liver disease
Silverio et al, 201536 Retrospective cohort To describe the clinical features of children treated for ALF Cuba Upper middle 5 Jan 11 Dec Evidence of liver damage in the absence of prior known chronic liver disease; altered coagulation, expressed as PT>15 s with encephalopathy; or PT>20 s with or without encephalopathy—all this within 8 weeks of onset of clinical symptoms
Somasekar et al, 201737 Retrospective cohort To investigate the causes of previously diagnosed indeterminate cases ALF USA High Jan 98 10 Dec US Acute Liver Failure Study Group case definition
Uddin Jamro et al, 201338 Retrospective cohort To study the aetiology, outcome and risk factors for FHF in children at a tertiary care hospital Pakistan Lower middle 7 Jul 12 Jun Presence of acute liver failure (coagulopathy PT>20 s or INR>2), HE without pre-existing liver disease, within 8 weeks of the onset of clinical liver disease
Tsunoda et al, 201739 Prospective cohort To identify the roles of CMV, EBV and HHV in immunocompetent children with ALF not resulting from hepatitis virus Japan High 7 Jan 13 Dec Liver dysfunction with elevated AST and ALT>30 IU/L
Zhao et al, 201440 Retrospective cohort To investigate aetiologies and outcomes of children with ALF China Middle 7 Jan 12 Dec Coagulopathy (PTA≤40% or INR≥1.5 excluding haematologic diseases) and jaundice (Tbil ≥ 171 μmol/L) within 4 weeks in a child without pre-existing liver diseases

AHF, acute hepatic failure; ALF, acute liver failure; ALT, alanine aminotransferase; AP, alkaline phosphatase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; CMV, cytomegalovirus; EBV, Epstein-Barr virus; ELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; FHF, fulminant hepatic failure; HE, hepatic encephalopathy; HEV, hepatitis E virus; HHV, human herpesvirus; INR, international normalised ratio; PT, prothrombin time; PTA, plasma thromboplastin antecedent; s, second; TSB, total serum bilirubin.