Table 2.
Three categories of RBEC assessment method categories and methods under each category, as well as data inputs, GIS data processing, spatial/spatiotemporal operations, data outputs, and counts of each method that has been applied by reviewed studies.
Category | Method | Data Inputs | GIS Data Processing | Spatial Averaging Operations | Data Outputs | # of Studies |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Domain-based Exposure Assessment | Visual Inspection | Aerial images, TAGA point data | N/A | Manually assign each point with the designated BE domains by visually identifying its spatial relationships with image pixels that represent BE domains (e.g., home, park) | A database with built environment contextual domains that link to epoch-level physical activity outcomes | 6 |
Spatial Join | BE GIS layers, TAGA point data | 1. construct GIS layers for specific domains (e.g., home, school, park) | Perform spatial join operation to assign each TAGA point with designated BE domains (e.g., home, park) if the point falls into polygon geometries that represent those domains in GIS | The same as above | 34 | |
Hierarchical Domain Assignment | The same as above | 1. perform trip identification and trip mode classification on TAGA point with data processing software (e.g., PALMsa); 2. the same as step 1 above |
In a hierarchical order (e.g., home > school > transport > leisure > others), perform spatial join operation as described in Spatial Join method. | The same as above | 13 | |
Buffer-based Exposure Assessment | Point Buffer | The same as above | 1. buffer TAGA point data by a pre-determined radius distance | Measure desired BE characteristics (e.g., walkability) within each point buffer. | A database with spatially-averaged built environment characteristics that link to epoch-level physical activity outcomes | 14 |
Trip Buffer | The same as above | 1. the same as step 1 of Hierarchical Domain Assignment; 2. connect TAGA points that represent trips of interest (e.g., home/school commutes) into lines and generate buffer polygons along lines in GIS software |
Measure desired BE characteristics (e.g., walkability) within trip buffers in GIS. | A database with spatially-averaged built environment characteristics that link to trip-level physical activity outcomes | 3 | |
Activity Space-based Exposure Assessment | Direct Path Area | The same as above | 1. connect temporally-integrated (e.g., 1 day) TAGA points as lines based on timestamp sequences and aggregate the epoch-level PA outcome by the same temporal unit with GIS software; 2. buffer each trajectory by a distance and merge all buffers to generate direct path area polygons in GIS; |
Measure desired BE characteristics (e.g., walkability) within activity space polygons in GIS. | A database with spatially-averaged built environment characteristics that link to day or any study period level physical activity outcomes | 5 |
Minimum Convex Hull | The same as above | 1. execute the “minimal bounding geometry” operation in GIS to temporally-integrated (e.g., 1 day) TAGA points to generate minimum convex hull polygons and aggregate the epoch-level PA outcome by the same temporal unit | The same as above. | The same as above | 3 | |
Standard Deviation Ellipse | The same as above | 1. the same as the Minimum Convex Hull method above; however, in step 1, the “standard deviation ellipse” operation is executed to generate ellipse polygonsb | The same as above. | The same as above | 2 | |
Kernel Density Estimation | GPS and Accelerometry datasets, BE GIS layers | 1. create radius buffers around hostpots detected for each participant and average built environment characteristics within the buffer as RBECs exposure | 1. Derive a list of all visits over the period made to each detected location (i.e. space-and-time peaks from GPS data) with their start and end times by applying the kernel density estimation method; 2. Implement a web-survey to obtain trip origins and destinations based on locations detected. |
A database with time-weighted spatially-averaged built environment characteristics that link to day or any study period level physical activity outcomes | 2 | |
Total Counts | 79c |
Notes. BE=Built Environment, PA=Physical Activity, RBECs = Relevant Built Environment Contexts, TAGA point data = time-aligned GPS accelerometry point data
Physical Activity and Location Measurement System (University of California San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA).
A ellipse polygon generated from the “Standard Deviation Ellipse” starts from the geographic centroid of the GIS points and covers one-standard deviation (68% of points) from the center, with major and minor axes determined by directional distributions of those points.
The Hirsh et al. (2016) applied all three Activity Space-based methods and the Zenk et al. (2011) applied two Activity Space-based methods; therefore, the Total Counts were subtracted by 3 when adding up all counts.