Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 26;166:112445. doi: 10.1016/j.bios.2020.112445

Table 2.

Overview of major characteristics of classified POC CRISPR nucleotide sensing applications.

Type Method sensor type Effector Ampli-fication Quanti-tative LODa Multi-plex Read-out Time Sample type Target Type disease/pathogen Refs
II NASBACC Toehold switch Cas9 NASBA Semi 1 fM No Colorimetric 3 h Raw DNA Zika virus Pardee et al. (2016)
CASFLA LFA (d)Cas9 PCR/RPA Yes 82 aM No Colorimetric 1–1.5 h Raw DNA African Swine Fever Wang et al., 2020
Cas9nAR LFA Cas9 SDA Semi 100 copies No Colorimetric ~3 h Pre-treated DNA Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli Wang et al., 2020
- LFA Cas9 - Semi 1 nM No Colorimetric < 30 min Pre-treated DNA Various pathogens Hu et al. (2020)
CRISPR-chip Field-effect transistor Cas9 Yes 2.3 fM No Potentiometry 15 min Pre-treated DNA Duchenne muscular dystrophy Hajian et al. (2019)
Micro array dCas9 Yes 10 CFU/ml No Fluorescence 30 min Raw DNA MRSA bacterium Guk et al. (2017)
Nanoelectrokinetic chip dCas9 No No Fluorescence <1 h Pre-treated DNA HIV Lee et al. (2018)
SMR sensor dCas9 (rt-)RPA Yes ~0.6 fM No Change in R.I. ~20 min Raw DNA/RNA Tick born disease Koo et al., 2018a
Nanopore sensors dCas9 No Single copy No Resistive pulse 1–2 h Synthetic DNA Yang et al. (2018)
Nanopore sensors dCas9 No Single copy No Resistive pulse <1h Synthetic DNA Weckman et al. (2019)
V SCAN Nanopore sensors Cas12a - No 10 nM No Resistive pulse 1 h Synthetic DNA HIV Nouri et al. (2020)
One-pot reaction Cas12a LAMP Yes 0.05% GM DNA No Fluorescence 45 min Pre-treated DNA GMOs Wu et al. (2020a)
ULC One-pot reaction Cas12a Uracil-LAMP Yes Single copy No Fluorescence <1 h Pre-treated DNA Citrus greening disease Qian et al. (2019)
One-pot reaction Cas12a LAMP Yes ~1 fM No Fluorescence <1 h Raw DNA African Swine Fever Qian et al. (2020)
Portable microplatereader Cas12a Semi 1 pM/0.2 nM Yes Fluorescence 1 h Pre-treated DNA African Swine Fever He et al. (2020)
DAMR 3D printer inset/tube Cas12a RPA Yes 10-100 copies Yes Fluorescence <1 h Raw DNA HPV Yin et al. (2020)
IMPACT PDMS micropillar chip Cas12a Semi 0.1–10 nM No Fluorescence ~10 min Raw DNA African Swine Fever Hass et al. (2020)
CORDS LFA Cas12a RAA No 10 fM No Fluorescence/Colorimetric ~1h Pre-treated DNA African Swine Fever Bai et al. (2019)
- LFA Cas12a RPA No 10 pM No Fluorescence/Colorimetric 15–60 min Raw RNA SARS-CoV-2 Curti et al. (2020)
DETECTR LFA Cas12a RT-LAMP No 20 aM No Fluorescence/Colorimetric 30–40 min Pre-treated RNA SARS-CoV-2 Broughton et al. (2020)
AIOD-CRISPR One-pot reaction Cas12a RPA Semi ~1 copy No Fluorescence/Colorimetric <1 h Pre-treated DNA SARS-Cov-2/HIV Ding et al. (2020)
V CIA-LFB LFA Cas12a LAMP No 3.4 aM No Colorimetric 30min–1 h Raw DNA P.aeruginosa Mukama et al. (2020a)
CIA-LFB LFA Cas12a PCR/LAMP Semi 3.1 aM No Colorimetric <1 h Raw DNA HPV Mukama et al. (2020b)
LFA Cas12a RPA Semi 0.24 fM No Colorimetric ~3 h Raw DNA HPV Tsou et al. (2019)
MAV-chip Platinum nanoreporter Cas12a Yes 10pM Yes Colorimetric ~1 h Pre-treated DNA Liver cancer Shao et al. (2019)
CRISPR-μPAD ssDNA-anchored hydrogel on paper fluidics Cas12a Yes 400 pM No Colorimetric 1–4h Synthetic DNA/RNA Ebola virus English et al. (2019)
RT-RPA 11 aM No Electronic
E-CRISPR Electrochemical chip Cas12a Yes 1 pM/0.2 nM No Electrochemical ~1 h Raw DNA HPV/Parvovirus Dai et al. (2019)
Electrochemical chip Cas12a Yes 30 pM/100 pM* No Electrochemical ~1 h Pre-treated/Raw* DNA HPV Zhang et al., 2020
HOLMESv2 One-pot reaction Cas12b LAMP Yes 10aM/1pM* No Fluorescence <1h Pre-treated/Raw* DNA/RNA Several viruses and DNA methylation L. Li et al. (2019)
CasDetec One-pot reaction Cas12b RT-RAA Semi 1x104 copies/mL No Fluorescence/Colorimetric <1 h Pre-treated DNA SARS-CoV-2 Guo et al. (2020a)
- AuNP colorimetric Cas12a LAMP Yes 50 aM No Colorimetric - Synthetic DNA Hepatitis B R. Zhou et al. (2020)
VI Fluorescence reader with paper fluidics Cas13a Yes 3.7 nM No Fluorescence 20 min Synthetic RNA Katzmeier et al. (2019)
LFA Cas13a RT RPA No 90 aM–9 aM No Fluorescence/Colorimetric <2 h Raw RNA Zika/dengue virus Myhrvold et al. (2018)
SHERLOCKv2 LFA Cas13a RPA No 20–200 aM No Fluorescence/Colorimetric <1 h Pre-treated RNA SARS-CoV-2 F. Zhang et al. (2020)
SHERLOCKv2 LFA Cas13a RT-RPA No 0.5–2.3 aM No Colorimetric <2 h Raw DNA BK polyomavirus and cytomegalovirus Kaminski et al. (2020)
LFA Cas13a RPA No 10 copies No Colorimetric ~1 h Pre-treated DNA/RNA White Spot Syndrome Virus Sullivan et al. (2019)
LFA Cas13a RPA No ~1.x105 copies/ml No Colorimetric 1–2 h Pre-treated RNA Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus
PECL-CRISPR Electrochemiluminescence Cas13a EXPAR Yes 1 fM No Electrochemiluminescence < 2 h Pre-treated miRNA Various tumor cells Zhou et al., 2020
Multi AuNP colorimetric Cas12a/Cas13a RPA/PCR Semi 200 copies No Colorimetric >20 min Pre-treated DNA/RNA Various pathogenic bacteria Yuan et al. (2020)
E-DNA Electrochemical chip Cas9/Cas12a Yes ~10 fM- 100 fM No Electrochemical <1 h Raw DNA Parvovirus Xu et al. (2020)
a

All values are taken from the original publications.