Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: Anim Cogn. 2020 Apr 30;23(4):795–805. doi: 10.1007/s10071-020-01385-0

Table 1.

Description of cognitive tasks, cognitive processes the task was designed to test, number of trials conducted per task, number of individuals included in analysis, and number of breeds included in analysis

Task Description Cognitive processes Trials Total dogs Total breeds

Eye contact The owner holds a treat to their face and records if and when the dog breaks eye contact within 90 s Social engagement 3 4359 65
Arm pointing The owner places one treat to their right and left, points to one treat location, and records the location the dog first approaches Social cognition/communication 6 4367 65
Foot pointing The owner places one treat to their right and left, extends their foot toward one treat location, and records the location the dog first approaches Social cognition/communication 6 4071 63
Delay of gratification Inhibition/self-control 6 2826 51
Watching condition The owner places the treat in front of the dog and verbally commands the dog not to take the treat. The owner records the duration of time until the dog takes the treat, up to 90 s 2 2826 51
Closed eyes condition Same as above, with the owner closing their eyes 2 2826 51
Turned back condition Same as above, with the owner turning their back 2 2826 51
Memory vs. pointing In view of the dog, the owner places a treat under one of two cups, then proceeds to point to the other cup. The owner records which location the dog first approaches Bias for information from memory vs. communication 6 2346 48
Memory vs. smell Allowing the dog to see, the owner places a treat under one of two cups, then blocks the dog's view while switching the position of the treat. The owner records which location the dog first approaches Bias for information from memory vs. olfaction 4 2187 47
Delayed memory In full view of the dog, the owner places a treat under one of two cups and then waits 60, 90, 120, and 150 s (across four trials) before releasing the dog. Then the owner records which location the dog first approaches Short-term memory/sustained attention 4 2124 47
Inferential reasoning The owner appears to place treats under two cups, while only baiting one. The owner raises the empty cup to show it is empty and records which location the dog first approaches Inferential reasoning/reasoning by exclusion 4 1737 42
Physical reasoning Blocking the dog's view, the owner places two pieces of folded paper on the floor. The owner places a treat under one paper so that the paper is elevated by the treat while the other paper is flat and records which location the dog first approaches Physical causality/inferential reasoning 4 1654 40