Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 27;15(7):e0236445. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0236445

Table 2. Subgroup analysis of meta-analysis.

Subgroup Number of studies Estimated effect size Heterogeneity
HR 95% CI Z-value P-value I2 (%)
1. CRP
Quality of study
 High 5 2.042 1.425–2.928 3.887 <0.001 42.515
 Low 6 1.446 1.044–2.004 2.217 0.027 90.921
Stage
 Advanced* 6 1.649 1.112–2.445 2.489 0.013 91.546
 Stage I–III 5 1.667 1.183–2.348 2.923 0.003 62.656
Cut-off value (mg/dL)
 CRP < 1.0 5 1.591 1.121–2.258 2.600 0.009 72.654
 CRP ≥ 1.0 6 1.686 1.218–2.335 3.145 0.002 79.409
Chemotherapy
 Included 2 2.582 1.536–4.341 3.579 <0.001 41.339
 Excluded 9 1.457 1.174–1.809 3.413 0.001 68.040
Study design
 Prospective 1 2.235 1.859–2.687 8.558 <0.001 <0.001
 Retrospective 10 1.545 1.226–1.948 3.684 <0.001 72.134
2. NLR
Quality of study
 High 8 1.401 1.251–1.570 5.836 <0.001 5.709
 Low 16 1.732 1.509–1.987 7.815 <0.001 54.168
Stage
 Advanced* 14 1.603 1.468–1.750 10.518 <0.001 <0.001
 Stage I–III 10 1.586 1.288–1.953 4.348 <0.001 74.883
Country
 Asia 20 1.638 1.460–1.837 8.428 <0.001 57.571
 Western 4 1.413 1.114–1.792 2.849 0.004 <0.001
Cut-off value (mg/dL)
 NLR ≤ 3 14 1.562 1.359–1.795 6.284 <0.001 66.679
 NLR > 3 10 1.710 1.481–1.975 7.320 <0.001 <0.001
Chemotherapy
 Included 4 1.550 1.190–2.019 3.252 <0.001 24.871
 Excluded 20 1.615 1.443–1.809 8.310 <0.001 55.537
Study design
 Prospective 6 1.569 1.400–1.758 7.759 <0.001 <0.001
 Retrospective 18 1.608 1.405–1.840 6.891 <0.001 59.778
3. GPS/mGPS
Quality of study
 High 7 1.731 1.363–2.197 4.506 <0.001 65.037
 Low 8 1.433 1.000–2.053 1.960 0.050 74.725
Stage
 Advanced* 10 1.474 1.132–1.918 2.884 0.004 64.636
 Stage I–III 5 1.998 1.393–2.865 3.764 <0.001 81.592
Country
 Asia 10 1.559 1.205–2.018 3.375 <0.001 74.134
 Western 5 1.851 1.387–2.470 4.184 <0.001 48.054
Chemotherapy
 Included 6 1.149 0.679–1.943 0.517 0.605 77.853
 Excluded 9 1.763 1.455–2.136 5.786 <0.0001 62.488
Study design
 Prospective 7 2.000 1.606–2.491 6.188 <0.001 42.906
 Retrospective 8 1.319 0.976–1.784 1.800 0.072 74.911

*the inclusion of patients with stage IV gastric cancer.

the inclusion of patients with neo- or adjuvant chemotherapy. CRP, c-reactive protein; GPS, Glasgow prognostic score; HR, hazard ratio; mGPS, modified Glasgow prognostic score; NLR, neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio.