Table 3.
Study characteristics
Author (year) | Country | Model | Patient population | N = | Average age (years) | Study design and evidence score | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nicholson et al. (2020) [10] | United Kingdom | Store-and-forward | Teleconsultative service for general dermatology | 60 | 78% ≤ | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
51% Female | 55 | ||||||
65% White | |||||||
Mehrtens et al. (2019) [11] | United Kingdom | Store-and-forward | Teleconsultative service for general dermatology | 37 | − | Retrospective observational study, 3 | Primary: Number of consultations, number of face-to-face appointments avoided |
Secondary: Patient satisfaction | |||||||
Baranowski et al. (2019) [18] | United States | Store-and-forward in comparison to teleconsultative method | Teleconsultative service for Department of Veterans Affairs | 100 | 60.9 | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
60% White | |||||||
36% Black or African American | |||||||
Wang et al. (2018) [22] | Taiwan | Store-and-forward | Follow-up care for cosmetic dermatology patients | 28 | − | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
Bosanac et al. (2018) [26] | United States | Store-and-forward | Follow-up care for actinic keratoses patients receiving topical therapy | 13 | 67 | Randomized controlled trial, 1 | Primary: number of treatment doses, times contacted clinic, patient satisfaction |
96% Male | |||||||
Lim et al. (2018) [16] | Australia | Store-and-forward | Patients treated for early stage melanoma who required follow-up via teledermatology | 262 | 64.3 | Retrospective observational study, 3 | Primary: determine proportion of adults who preferred standard scheduled visits or fewer follow-up visits using teledermatology |
36% Female | |||||||
Rajda et al. (2018) [27] | United States | Store-and-forward | General dermatology consultation service | 152 | 37.8 | Case–control study, 2 | Primary: access, satisfaction, utilization, costs |
Fiks et al. (2018) [19] | United States | Store-and-forward | Pediatric dermatology patients | 197 | 7.3 | Prospective comparative study, 2 | Primary: feasibility study for store-and-forward application; general satisfaction |
67% White | |||||||
Marchell et al. (2017) [28] | United States | Controlled study comparing in-person exam to store-and-forward to live-interactive | Patients cycled through all 3 modalities | 191 | − | Quasi-randomized control trial, 2 | Primary: Patient and provider satisfaction with teledermatology; Absolute preference of in-person, store-and-forward, or live-interactive teledermatology |
Pathipati et al. (2016) [24] | United States | Store-and-forward | General dermatology service | 38 | 39.3 | Case series study, 4 | Primary: Provider confidence in diagnosis; time to consult |
84% Female | |||||||
Secondary: Patient satisfaction | |||||||
Chee et al. (2016) [29] | Australia | Store-and-forward | Cosmetic laser resurfacing follow-up | 24 | − | Retrospective observational study, 3 | Primary: Patient satisfaction |
Bianciardi et al. (2016) [20] | Italy | Store-and-forward | Pediatric dermatology wound care follow-up | 19 | − | Case series study, 4 | Primary: Patient satisfaction |
Livingstone et al. (2015) [30] | United Kingdom | Store-and-forward | General adult dermatology | 129 | − | Retrospective observational study, 3 | Primary: Cost-effectiveness and patient satisfaction |
Ford et al. (2015) [31] | United Kingdom | Store-and-forward | 5 general teledermatology practices | 28 | − | Prospective comparative study, 2 | Primary: Reduction of secondary care referrals |
Secondary: patient satisfaction | |||||||
Quran et al. (2015) [17] | Jordan | Live-interactive | Teleconsultation services provided to 2 rural hospitals | 88 | − | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
Frühauf et al. (2015) [32] | Austria | Store-and-forward | Acne patients followed for isotretinoin therapy | 69 | 18 | Randomized control trial, 1 | Primary: therapeutic outcomes and adverse reactions |
25 Females | |||||||
44 Males | Secondary: patient satisfaction | ||||||
Lester et al. (2014) [25] | United States | Store-and-forward | PCP teletriage for dermatologic cases; | 63 | − | Case series study, 4 | Primary: number of secondary referrals |
Department of Veterans Affairs | |||||||
Secondary: patient satisfaction | |||||||
Kaliyadan et al. (2013) [23] | Saudi Arabia | Store-and-forward | General dermatology | 161 | − | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: diagnostic concordance; patient satisfaction |
Hsueh et al. (2012) [12] | United States | Store-and-forward | General dermatology, consult service; Department of Veterans Affairs | 196 | 71 | Case–control study, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
97% Male | |||||||
Frühauf et al. (2012) [13] | Austria | Store-and-forward | Patients were followed for response to psoriasis therapy | 10 | 40 | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
60% Male | |||||||
Koller et al. (2011) [14] | Austria | Store-and-forward | Patients were followed for response to biologic psoriasis therapy | 19 | 46.2 | Case–control study, 4 | Primary: symptom management, safety and adverse events |
12 Males | |||||||
7 Females | Secondary: patient satisfaction | ||||||
Azfar et al. (2011) [15] | Botswana | Store-and-forward | Patients with HIV and mucocutaneous complaints | 89 | 71% were 31–50 | Cross-sectional survey, 4 | Primary: patient satisfaction |
34 (44%) Males | |||||||
44% Unemployed | |||||||
Thind et al. (2011) [21] | United Kingdom | Store-and-forward | General teledermatology consultation | 23 | 54 | Case–control study, 3 | Primary: patient satisfaction, diagnostic concordance, secondary referrals |