Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 15;23:100307. doi: 10.1016/j.jbo.2020.100307

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

Author Year Country microRNAs Regulation mode Sample size
Speci-men Diagnostic power
OS patients Healthy Sen (%) Spe (%) AUC
Single microRNA
Zhu [29] 2017 China miR-17-5p Upregulated 62 36 Plasma 0.500 0.972 0.793
Fujiwara [30] 2017 Japan miR-17-5p Upregulated 14 22 Serum 0.643 0.846 0.720
Fujiwara [30] 2017 Japan miR-25-3p Upregulated 14 22 Serum 0.714 0.923 0.868
Tang [31] 2015 China miR-27a Upregulated 166 60 Serum 0.700 0.983 0.867
Zhang [32] 2017 China miR-27b Upregulated 51 51 Serum 0.778 0.867 0.863
Zhi [33] 2016 China miR-34a Downregulated 50 50 Serum 0.867 0.686 0.830
Wang [34] 2017 China miR-34a Downregulated 120 87 Serum 0.680 0.920 0.830
Yao [35] 2018 China miR-101 Downregulated 152 70 Serum 0.790 0.829 0.850
Cong [36] 2018 China miR-124 Downregulated 114 50 Serum 0.798 0.860 0.846
Xiao [37] 2016 China miR-125b Downregulated 20 20 Serum 0.900 0.950
Zhou [25] 2018 China miR-139-5p Downregulated 98 50 Serum 0.765 0.800 0.846
Zhang [38] 2020 China miR-144 Downregulated 51 48 Serum 0.738 0.882 0.852
Ma [39] 2014 China miR-148a Downregulated 89 89 Plasma 0.697 0.831 0.783
Wang [40] 2015 China miR-152 Downregulated 80 20 Serum 0.925 0.962 0.956
Wang [41] 2015 China miR-191 Upregulated 100 20 Serum 0.740 1 0.858
Shi [42] 2020 China miR-194 Downregulated 124 60 Serum 0.842 0.791 0.855
Cai [43] 2015 China miR-195 Downregulated 166 60 Serum 0.880 0.833 0.892
Zhou [44] 2015 China miR-199a-5p Upregulated 60 60 Serum 0.883 0.767 0.861
Yang [45] 2015 China miR-211 Upregulated 108 50 Serum 0.657 1 0.844
Zhang [46] 2016 China miR-222 Downregulated 57 57 Serum 0.667 0.842 0.811
Dong [47] 2016 China miR-223 Downregulated 122 50 Serum 0.895 0.972 0.926
Liu [48] 2019 China miR-223 Downregulated 53 30 Serum 0.736 0.600 0.747
Zhang [49] 2019 China miR-223 Downregulated 38 38 Serum 0.763 0.947 0.900
Liu [50] 2016 China miR-300 Upregulated 114 114 Serum 0.842 0.886 0.885
Cao [51] 2016 China miR-326 Downregulated 60 20 Serum 0.837 0.945 0.897
Liu [27] 2018 China miR-375 Downregulated 95 95 Serum 0.840 0.844 0.830
Wang [52] 2017 China miR-491-5p Downregulated 72 40 Serum 0.720 0.860 0.834
Li [53] 2018 China miR-542-3p Upregulated 76 76 Serum 0.778 0.936 0.841
Liu [48] 2019 China miR-586 Upregulated 53 30 Serum 0.642 0.700 0.743
Huang [26] 2019 China miR-663a Upregulated 50 50 Plasma 0.674 0.898 0.860



microRNA clusters
Ouyang [54] 2013 China miRNA clusters
(miR-21, miR-199a-3p, miR-143)
Downregulated 40 40 Plasma 0.905 0.938 0.953
Ren [55] 2014 china miRNA clusters
(miR-199b-5p/miR-124)
Upregulated 22 30 Plasma 0.960 0.970 0.993
Lian [56] 2015 China miRNA clusters
(miR-195-5p, miR-199a-3p, miR-320a, miR-374a-5p)
Upregulated 90 90 Plasma 0.911 0.944 0.961
Liu [48] 2019 China miRNA clusters
(miR-586, miR-223)
Upregulated 53 30 Serum 0.887 0.634 0.813