Ziogas 2009.
Methods | Evaluates the reporting quality of published RCTs concerning myeloid haematologic malignancies according to the CONSORT Statement | |
Data | 74 pre‐CONSORT RCTs compared with 187 post CONSORT RCTs | |
Comparisons | Title and abstract, background, participants, interventions, objectives, outcomes, sample size, sequence generation, allocation concealment, implementation, blinding any, statistical methods, participant flow, recruitment, baseline data, numbers analysed, outcomes and estimation, ancillary analyses, adverse events, interpretation, generalisability, overall evidence | |
Outcomes | Cross‐sectional sample before and after CONSORT publication | |
Included number of RCTs, Journals | 261, not reported | |
Checklist version used | 1996 | |
Field of Study | Myeloid leukaemia and myelodysplastic syndromes | |
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Item | Authors' judgement | Description |
Large Cohort ? | Yes | Over 2 decades, large number of studies, wide database search |
Blinding? | Unclear | Not reported |
Confounding by journal quality? | Unclear | Quote: "The RCTs of major IF journals have adhered better to the CONSORT statement." |
Outcome Reporting? | Yes | No evidence of outcome reporting |
Multiple raters? | Yes | Quote: "No pilot training of the data extraction was performed." |
Rater agreement? | Yes | Not reported |
Blinding, quality assessment? | Yes | Not applicable |
BMJ: British Medical Journal CI: confidence interval CONSORT: Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease ECTR: endoscopic carpal tunnel release ITT: intention‐to‐treat
ICC: Intra‐Class Correlation Coefficient
ICJME: Iternational Commitee of Medical Journal Editors
JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association
ME: Managing Editor NEJM: New England Journal of Medicine
NPT: Non‐pharmocological Trials OCTR: open carpal tunnel release
PRO: Patient reported outcomes RCT: randomised controlled trial STRICTA: Standards for Reporting Interventions in Controlled Trials of Acupuncture TCM: Traditional Chinese Medicine