Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 31;2014(1):CD006546. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006546.pub3

2. Intervention Characteristics.

Study Kin Placement Type Placement Timing Length of Stay Data Collection
Akin 2011 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 30 ‐ 42 months
Barth 1994 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Belanger 2002 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 29.0 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 31.0 months Cross‐sectional
Benedict 1996a Licensed First   Longitudinal ‐ 4 years
Bennett 2000 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Berger 2009 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal
Berrick 1994 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 39.0 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 28.0 months
Cross‐sectional
Berrick 1997 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 18.0 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 18.0 months
Cross‐sectional
Berrick 1999 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ up to 7 years
Bilaver 1999 Not Reported/Unclear Only   Longitudinal ‐ 1 ‐ 2 years
Brooks 1998 Not Reported/Unlcear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 43.2 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 32.4 months
Cross‐sectional
Chamberlain 2006 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 1 year
Chapman 2004 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 12.0 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 12.0 months
Cross‐sectional
Chew 1998 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Christopher 1998 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Cross‐sectional
Clyman 1998 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 21.2 months
(F) ‐ OOH ‐ 17.5 months
Cross‐sectional
Cole 2006 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Connell 2006a Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ up to 5 years
Connell 2006b Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 5 years
Courtney 1995 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Longitudinal ‐ 3 years
Courtney 1996a Not Reported/Unclear Last   Cross‐sectional
Courtney 1996b Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Courtney 1997a Not Reported/Unclear First (Reunification)
 Last (re‐entry)   Longitudinal ‐ 6 years
Courtney 1997b Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 4 years
Davis 2005 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 16.0 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 39.0 months
 (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 80.0 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 65.0 months
Cross‐sectional
De Robertis 2004 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 4 ‐ 8 years
Del Valle 2009 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 57.6 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 40.8 months
Cross‐sectional
Dunn 2010 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Farmer 2010 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 18 months
Farruggia 2009 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Cross‐sectional
Ford 2007 Licensed (52%) Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 36 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 30 months
Cross‐sectional
Frame 2000 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Longitudinal ‐ 4 ‐ 6 years
Frame 2002 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 3.5 ‐ 4.5 years
Fuller 2005 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Geenen 2006 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reporte/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Grogan‐Kaylor 2000 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Harris 2003 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Helton 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal
Holtan 2005 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 61.2 months
 (F) ‐ Placement ‐ 68.4 months Cross‐sectional
Hurlburt 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 4‐12 months
Iglehart 1994 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Iglehart 1995 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Jenkins 2002 Licensed Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 31.6 months
 (F) ‐ Placement ‐ 19.3 months Cross‐sectional
Johnson 2005 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 15 months
Jones‐Karena 1998 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Jonson‐Reid 2003 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Longitudinal ‐ 4.5 years
Keller 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Koh 2008a Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 1 year
Koh 2008b Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 3 years
Koh 2009 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 1 year
Landsverk 1996 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Lawler 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Lernihan 2006 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 46.8 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 60 months
Cross‐sectional
Leslie 2000a Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 1.5 years
Linares 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Lutman 2009 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 3‐10 years
McCarthy 2007 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
McIntosh 2002 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
McMillen 2004 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
McMillen 2005 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Mennen 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Metzger 1997 Unlicensed Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 74.0 months
 (F) ‐ Placement ‐ 77.8 months Cross‐sectional
Metzger 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 74 months
(F) ‐ OOH ‐ 78 months
Cross‐sectional
Mosek 2001 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 104.4 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 126.0 months Cross‐sectional
Orgel 2007 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unlcear   Cross‐sectional
Pabustan‐Claar 2007a Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 6 years
Palacios 2009 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Ringeisen 2009 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 5 ‐ 6 years
Rubin 2008 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitunidal ‐ 18 and 36 months
Rudenberg 1991 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Ryan 2010a Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 53.2 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 53.7 months
Longitudinal ‐ 6.1 years
Sakai 2011 Not Reported/Unclear First (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 26 months
(F) ‐ OOH ‐ 19.3 months
Longitudinal ‐ 3 years
Sallnas 2004 Not Reported/Unclear First   Longitudinal ‐ 5 years
Scannapieco 1997 Licensed Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 33.6 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 17.8 months Cross‐sectional
Schneiderman 2010 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unlcear   Cross‐sectional
Shin 2003 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 96.0 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 96.0 months Cross‐sectional
Sivright 2004 Not Reported/Unclear First (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 47.3 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 43.8 months Cross‐sectional
Smith 2002 Unlicensed First (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 13.4 months
 (F) ‐ Placement ‐ 5.5 months Longitudinal ‐ 2 ‐ 3 years
Smith 2003 Not Reported/Unclear Last   Longitudinal ‐ 11 months
Sripathy 2004 Licensed Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Strijker 2003 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Strijker 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 13.2 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 20.4 months
Longitudinal ‐ 2.33 years
Surbeck 2000 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 22.9 months
 (F) ‐ Placement ‐ 27.0 months Cross‐sectional
Tarren‐Sweeney 2006a Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Tarren‐Sweeney 2006b Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Tarren‐Sweeney 2008a Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Tarren‐Sweeney 2008b Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Testa 1999 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 1 ‐ 3 years
Testa 2001 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 63.1 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 52.8 months Longitudinal ‐ up to 8 years
Timmer 2004 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Tompkins 2003 Licensed and Unlicensed Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 31.3 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 31.0 months Cross‐sectional
USDHHS 2005 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Valicenti‐McDermott 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear (K) ‐ Placement ‐ 38.4 months
(F) ‐ Placement ‐ 14.4 months
(K) ‐ OOH ‐ 45.6 months
(F) ‐ OOH ‐ 32.4 months
Cross‐sectional
Villagrana 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Vogel 1999 Not Reported/Unclear First (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 18.8 months
 (F) ‐ OOH ‐ 13.8 months Longitudinal ‐ up to 2 years
Wells 1999 Not Reported/Unclear First (Reunification)
 Last (re‐entry)   Longitudinal ‐ 3 years
Wilson 1999 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Winokur 2008 Not Reported/Unclear Last (K) ‐ OOH ‐ 12 months
(F) ‐ OOH ‐ 12 months
Longitudinal ‐ 1 year
Zima 2000 Not Reported/Unclear Not Reported/Unclear   Cross‐sectional
Zimmerman 1998 Not Reported/Unclear First   Cross‐sectional
Zinn 2009 Not Reported/Unlcear Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 5 ‐ 9 years
Zuravin 1993 Licensed Not Reported/Unclear   Longitudinal ‐ 5 years

OOH: out‐of‐home